Book Reviews - "Smallville" Young Adults Series
Smallville: GreedWriter: Cherie Bennett and Jeff Gottesfeld
Published by: Little, Brown, and Company (December 2003)
Reviewed by: Aaron Thall
Pete Ross needs money, and can't help but imagine what it'd be like to be able to live the good life... a mindset that leads him to one of his inevitable Luthor rants at the Talon. It's only exacerbated when Chloe fills Clark, Pete, and Lana in on Camp Charity (later Camp Freedom), a new venture by Lex Luthor to give underprivileged kids some summer fun in the great outdoors. Needing volunteers to help her (it's an assignment from the Daily Planet, where she's interning, for you continuity lovers), she ropes the gang in.
At the camp, Clark and Pete soon meet an up and coming basketball player named Will Perkins, a young man obsessed only with the almighty dollar, present to help with the camp only to fulfill a public service requirement before he can hit the big time. They also meet DeJuan Williams, a young and relatively withdrawn camper.
It isn't long before Pete realizes how good he has it, compared to the kids, and changes his dream to instead be Robin Hood, stealing from the rich and giving to the poor. And his plan? Challenge Will to a basketball game: Smallville vs. Metropolis, with the loser forking over $10,000. Pete begs Clark to help and refuses to take no for an answer. Clark is understandably reluctant.
When DeJuan begins to drown in the camp lake, Clark swims to the rescue, only to discover meteor rocks at the bottom. Both barely surviving, the aftermath is both obvious and inevitable: DeJuan's developed the ability to see into the future, and Clark wants to help the boy cope with his ability.
Eventually, Pete succeeds in getting Clark into the game and Smallville wins, but then Pete foolishly doubles the bet on a second game... And at the same time, Will discovers DeJuan's powers, and begins to see the potential for untold riches...
Story - 1: Do you know the feeling? That one you get when you're expecting a big exciting package, but when the doorbell rings, it's not the postman, but a flaming bag of dog poo?
This is that bag.
This story is so awful, so flawed, so totally wrong that it hurts my head to think about it. Here's the blow by blow:
1: Pete's behavior in this story is completely out of character. Pete would NEVER intentionally put Clark into a situation where his powers could come out, and certainly not for some stupid bet.
2: Pete would never bet a ton of money that he couldn't back up. That's just common sense. And doing so just because he knows someone with powers is doubly foolish, because it puts Clark into a situation that a true friend would never subject another person to. Here, Pete does it TWICE.
3: Will's a completely one note character... He possesses no depth. He's literally all surface, and NO ONE is like that in the real world.
4: Clark CHEATS for MONEY. That's just all KINDS of wrong right there.
5: DeJuan's powers fade when away from the camp. Bu-WHA?! KRYPTONITE POWERS DON'T WORK THAT WAY! WE'VE SEEN IT A HUNDRED TIMES ON THE SHOW! THEY DON'T GO AWAY JUST BECAUSE THEY'RE NOT NEAR THE RADIATION! It's an idiotic way to resolve the conflict, and proof that the "writers" (and I use that term loosely) wrote themselves into a corner.
6: Would the Daily Planet really send an intern to cover a story? Even a puff piece? I'm just saying, I'd TOTALLY send someone to cover Lex Luthor that has no real credentials and that's been getting my coffee for two weeks...
7: No one learns anything. Pete begins by ranting about how the rich give what's, for them, a paltry sum of money to charity... and it ends the same way... AFTER Lex saves his keister in the aftermath of the second game. No gratitude or new understanding... It makes Pete come out to be a total jerk.
By the same token, Clark learns that cheating is bad. Except he knew that to begin with. Of course, he did it again later on the TV show by playing football... So no lesson learned.
To summarize: Out of character behavior, stupid plot contrivances abound, flat villain, and Pete's a d*****bag.
Somebody get the garden hose. I need to stomp this flame out, and these are new shoes I'm wearing. This novel is a total failure on every conceivable level. An utter disaster. I paid a buck for it... I was overcharged.
Cover Art - 1: The standard promotional shots taken from episodes. The front doesn't even have the decency to have Pete on it... He's relegated to a tiny picture on the back. Instead, the cover image is Clark, in a suit, talking to Lex. Except that, y'know, they're wearing CAMPING GEAR IN THE STORY, NOT BUSINESS SUITS! BAKA! (smacks the person that picked that picture). The failure of this cover to convey the contents is entirely appropriate, considering the utter failure of this book in general.
Book ReviewsComic Book Novelizations:
- The Gospel According to the World's Greatest Superhero
- The Man From Krypton
- The Original Encyclopedia of Comic Book Heroes - Volume 3: Superman
- Superman on Film, Television, Radio and Broadway
- Beyond Lois Lane
- The DC Comics Action Figure Archive
- Superman vs. Hollywood
- Boys of Steel: The Creators of Superman
- Flights of Fantasy: The Unauthorized but True Story of Radio & TV's Adventures of Superman by Michael J. Hayde
- Our Hero: Superman on Earth by Tom De Haven
- Superman On Earth: Reflections of a Fan by Gary D. Robinson
- DC Super Heroes: The Ultimate Pop-Up Book by Matthew Reinhart
- The True Adventures of the World's Greatest Stuntman by Vic Armstrong
- The Ages of Superman: Essays on the Man of Steel in Changing Times
- Superman: The High-Flying History of America's Most Enduring Hero by Larry Tye
- Superman is an Arab by Joumana Haddad
- Superman is Jewish? by Harry Brod
- 100 Things Superman Fans Should Know & Do Before They Die by Joseph McCabe
- Superman: The Persistence of an American Icon by Ian Gordon
- DC: Women of Action by Shea Fontana
- Is Superman Circumcised?: The Complete Jewish History of the World's Greatest Hero by Roy Schwartz
- Adapting Superman: Essays on the Transmedia Man of Steel by John Darowski (Editor)
- Superman: Last Son of Krypton
- Superman: Miracle Monday
- The Further Adventures of Superman
- It's Superman! by Tom De Haven
- DC Universe: Last Sons
- DC Universe: Trail of Time
- Last Days of Krypton by Kevin J. Anderson
- Enemies & Allies by Kevin J. Anderson
- DC Super-Pets! by Picture Window Books
- Dear Justice League by Michael Northrop
- Dear Super-Villains by Michael Northrop
- Fallout (Lois Lane) by Gwenda Bond
- Double Down (Lois Lane) by Gwenda Bond
- Triple Threat (Lois Lane) by Gwenda Bond
- Superman: Dawnbreaker by Matt De La Pena
- Super Sons: Escape to Landis by author Ridley Pearson and illustrator Ileana Gonzales
- House of El - Book One: Shadow Threat by author Claudia Gray and illustrator Eric Zawadzki
- House of El - Book Two: The Enemy Delusion by author Claudia Gray and illustrator Eric Zawadzki
- Smallville: Strange Visitors
- Smallville: Dragon
- Smallville: Hauntings
- Smallville: Whodunnit
- Smallville: Shadows
- Smallville: Silence
- Smallville: Curse
- Smallville: City
- Smallville: Arrival
- Smallville: See No Evil
- Smallville: Flight
- Smallville: Animal Rage
- Smallville: Speed
- Smallville: Buried Secrets
- Smallville: Greed
- Smallville: Temptation
- Smallville: Sparks
- JLA: Batman - The Stone King
- JLA: Wonder Woman - Mythos
- JLA: The Flash - Stop Motion
- JLA: JLA - Exterminators
- JLA: Green Lantern - Hero's Quest
- JLA: Superman - The Never-Ending Battle
- Superman Returns: Strange Visitor
- Superman Returns: Novelization
- Superman Returns: Coming Home
- Superman Returns: Earthquake in Metropolis!
- Superman Returns: I am Superman!
- Superman Returns: Be A Hero!
- Superman Returns: Thank You, Superman!
- Superman Returns: The Movie Storybook
- Superman Returns: The Visual Guide
- Superman Returns: The Official Movie Guide