2004 Movie News Archives

Superman

August 4, 2004: Battle For Superman/Superboy Rights Continues

Newsarama have picked up the trail on the battle for Copyright control of Superman which raged as one of the most discussed topics on this website a few years ago. It seems the focus in the Superman copyright case has shifted from Superman to Superboy, and the battle for the right to Superman is joined by a Shuster. Here's an excerpt from the indepth article posted at Newsarama.com...

    With the bubbling finally coming to a boil, there have been several recent developments in the matter regarding the rights to Superman, and his creators (represented by their heirs and in one case, widow). Long-time readers will recall that in 1998, the widow and daughter of Superman co-creator Jerry Siegel filed paperwork terminating the transfer of copyright for Superman that the creators made to DC Comics. Reportedly, the Siegels were in negotiation with DC in regards to the rights, and those negotiations were never settled, and the rights to Superman are still in dispute.

    Now, add the boy. The Superboy, that is. According to various sources, Joanne Siegel and Laura Siegel Larson filed paperwork to terminate the transfer of copyright for Superboy. The paperwork was filed in November of 2002. Given the mandatory two years' notice, the termination will be fully effective on November 17, 2004.

    The case made for Superboy dates back to the early '40s, when Jerry Siegel created and submitted the idea of a Superman spin-off, Superboy to DC Comics. DC did not act to publish or further develop the character until Siegel was drafted into service in World War II, a time during which, Siegel often stated, he in no way could protect his interests in the character(s) he'd created.

    While both Siegel and Shuster had come to feel extremely disenfranchised by DC over the course of Superman's career (neither ever received an accounting o f how much revenue the character brought in for DC throughout the '40s), the creation (with no credit given to him) of Superboy was too much for Siegel, who filed suit against DC, and won in 1947, with the judge in the case stating that DC Comics acted illegally (DC claimed that Superboy was in reality, simply Superman, and was therefore the same character created by Siegel, and the creator was owed nothing).

    While the court agreed with Siegel and Shuster, the creators sold the rights to the character back to DC for $100,000 (given that the court ruled Siegel to be the creator, the sale was in fact, a transfer of the copyright). The Siegels have moved to terminate that transfer of copyright, which will take effect in November.

Read the complete article at the Newsarama website.



2004 Movie News

Listed below are all the Movie News items archived for 2004 organized into 5 categories:

New “Superman” Movie News:

Christopher Reeve Movie News: George Reeves Movie News: “Supergirl” Movie News: Other Movie News:

Back to the News Archive Contents page.

Back to the Latest News page.