“Batwoman” Episode Review – S01E09 “Crisis on Infinite Earths – Part Two”

Superman Homepage writer Michael Bailey has submitted his review of the 9th episode of Season 1 of “Batwoman” in which the group uses Ray’s (guest star Brandon Routh) invention to track new recruits to help save the universe. The Monitor (guest star LaMonica Garrett) sends Iris (guest star Candice Patton), Clark (guest star Tyler Hoechlin) and Lois (guest star Elizabeth Tulloch) in search of a mysterious Kryptonian, while Kate (Ruby Rose) and Kara (guest star Melissa Benoist) head out to find Bruce Wayne (guest star Kevin Conroy). In addition, Mia (guest star Katherine McNamara) challenges Sara (guest star Caity Lotz), Rory (guest star Dominic Purcell) discovers a hidden talent, and Lex Luthor (guest star Jon Cryer) returns.

Originally Aired: December 9, 2019
WRITTEN BY: Don Whitehead and Holly Henderson
DIRECTED BY: Laura Belsey

Ruby Rose (Kate Kane/Batwoman)
Camrus Johnson (Luke Fox)

Melissa Benoist (Kara/Supergirl)
LaMonica Garrett (Monitor)
Stephen Amell (Oliver Queen/Green Arrow)
Grant Gustin (Barry Allen/Flash)
Tyler Hoechlin (Clark Kent/Superman)
Elizabeth Tulloch (Lois Lane)
Brandon Routh (Ray Palmer/Atom)
Brandon Routh (Clark Kent/Superman)
Caity Lotz (Sarah Lance/White Canary)
Katherine McNamara (Mia Smoak/Green Arrow)
Jon Cryer (Lex Luthor)
Tom Welling (Clark Kent)
Erica Durance (Lois Lane)
Kevin Conroy (Bruce Wayne)
Audrey Marie Anderson (Lyla Michaels/Harbinger)
Matt Ryan (John Constantine)
Dominic Purcell (Rory)

5Rating – 5 (out of 5): Well…that was even better than I thought it would be.

It’s hard to put into words how I felt about this episode. It was so Superman heavy that part of me just wants to gush about all of the awesome moments and music cues. It might even be appropriate considering this is the Superman Homepage. But there were other aspects of the episode to discuss, so I’ll just get through those scenes first and then dine out on the three Clarks, two Lois Lanes, and a Lex in a pear tree that we got in this installment.

The idea that there are seven champions/paragons is an interesting wrinkle for the Crisis. The original comics weren’t structured like that, but it makes sense for this version. The scene where baby Jonathan’s crying kept interrupting the Monitor was a nice bit of comedy relief, as was Rory looking after the kid while everyone was universe jumping. The scenes with Kate and Bruce were a legitimate surprise. It was a bold move to make this Bruce Wayne darker. Part of me wonders if it was a commentary on how Batman was portrayed in BATMAN V SUPERMAN: DAWN OF JUSTICE. There were certainly references to DARK KNIGHT RETURNS in there. More than anything I like how Kate realized that this Bruce was not the hero they were looking for and that, as telegraphed as the moment was, she was meant to be the paragon they were looking for.

The resurrection of Oliver Queen was both surprising and not surprising. I honestly hadn’t given the matter much thought, but it’s an interesting place to go. It gave Barry, Sarah, and Mia something to do for the episode and it brought in John Constantine, which was also cool. I like that these episodes keep going in directions I haven’t seen and it gives Stephen Amell more screen time, so it’s a win-win all around.

Okay, now to the Superman portion of this review.

Jon Cryer continues to be a magnificent Lex Luthor. The idea of giving him the Book of Destiny, which he uses to kill Supermen from across the multiverse is a dark way to go, but it fits the character. I was worried they were going to try and make him a hero right off the bat, but no, he was the villain. I wish there had been more scenes with him and Tyler Hoechlin, but hopefully there will be time for that later. My only real quibble is this Lex not knowing that Clark Kent is Superman. I could no prize it by putting forth the theory that since Clark looks different on different worlds, that Clark would not always be Superman, but that’s a little thin.

As someone who had a complicated relationship with Smallville as it aired and came around to it after the series ended, the scenes with Tom Welling were everything I wanted them to be. He slid right back into the character, especially with the facial expressions, and Welling also seemed to be channeling a little John Schneider in the way he carried himself. I can see where some people might be disappointed that this Clark gave up his powers, but to me, that makes sense. I especially loved him saying, “I haven’t missed these conversations,” right before he knocked Lex to the ground. I also loved the dynamic between him and Lois. It was a great set of scenes and a perfect way to pay tribute to Smallville as a series.

All of that was just a warm-up to Brandon Routh returning to the role of Clark Kent and Superman. I don’t even know where to start. I have long felt that Routh was never the problem with Superman Returns and this episode proves why. Yes, he’s still channeling Reeve’s Superman (as opposed to Reeves’ Superman) but he made it look so effortless. His Clark was a bit mild mannered but had a lot of personality. The shift to Superman was flawless and hearing him say things like, “I can handle Luthor” or the reference to the Clark vs Superman fight in Superman III or the fact that Superman Returns still happened…it just felt so right. The blending of Kingdom Come minus Superman leaving humanity behind after Magog was acquitted was sad, but it also worked. The Easter egg of Routh grabbing Hoechlin like the cover of the JSA special was a nice touch.

And how awesome was it to see Ray and Clark share screen time? It was amazing to see Routh play the characters so differently.

I mean, I don’t care that the CGI looked a little ropey in places. To be fair, it was no worse than some of the shots in Superman Returns. Also, it was two Supermen fighting on the Daily Planet globe!

And the use of the Williams Love Theme and Main Theme made the hairs on my neck stand up. This might be my imagination, but the music cue as they entered the Daily Planet sounded a lot like Ottman’s Daily Planet music from Superman Returns.

More than anything, I loved how well Superman…all of the Supermen…were treated in this episode. I was impressed that Tyler called Routh “Kal” but Lois called him “Clark”. It was a subtle bit of writing, but it showed how Lois sees her husband. He’s not Superman. He’s not Kal-El. He’s Clark.

I’m still smiling over those scenes.

Oh yeah…Earth-75. I see what you did there.

Crisis continues to be amazing. The twist at the end with Lyla getting corrupted by the Anti-Monitor was right out of the original comics, though I continue to be amused at how often they redress the STAR Labs hallway set. The Anti-Monitor looks great and this crossover over continues to be more epic than Earth-X and more fun than Elseworlds, and I loved both of them.

Check out the “Supergirl – Episode Reviews” Contents page.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
December 10, 2019 1:34 am

Spoilers ahead!! I thought it was a step down from part one. Welling looked really good, aside from the salt and pepper hair, he looked ready for another season of Smallville. But the “twist” left me more than a little cold. Same with Kevin Conroy’s “twist”. Aside from being too short, Brandon Routh’s return as Clark Kent/Superman actually held my interest better than his previous feature film. Now for what really got my dander up, I even tweeted CW about it (it was the first ever tweet I’ve ever sent), the commercials were ridiculous! Seriously the show didn’t get a… Read more »

December 10, 2019 2:38 am
Reply to  afriend

Yeah I would have liked to have seen more of Routh’s Superman for this episode. Luckily we still have three more episodes to go. I’m thrilled that his Superman finally had a fight scene even if it was with Tyler’s Superman and showed how strong Superman should be(no offense Tyler, I like your version, but I like Brandon’s version more. Again no offense Tyler.). I didn’t like what they did with Kevin Conroy’s Batman. It was disrespectful to him in my opinion. So as I said before about Batwoman, I’m not a fan because they keep dissing Batman to make… Read more »

December 10, 2019 10:14 am
Reply to  afriend

lol… I know what you mean, but I don’t know if its padding they need for time or the extra revenue the commercials bring in to pay for all the stars….lol

December 10, 2019 10:58 am
Reply to  sman1938

I just wanted to point out that they used the John Williams Superman Theme for Brandon Routh’s Kingdom Come Superman!
😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀 😀

December 10, 2019 11:31 am
Reply to  Superman2878

And I laughed at the Superman III joke.

December 10, 2019 12:06 pm
Reply to  afriend

Me too haha it’s canon after all!

December 10, 2019 1:19 pm

First: Earth 2878’s Superman is right. (See what I did there?) Brandon NEEDS a Superman show. His electric in the role! He gives you shivers… the same shivers you got when Reeve first came out of the revolving door. Second: I’m torn about Tom’s part. He was very good in the scene, and at the time I was sure he was intentionally playing it like John Schneider, which was a terrific choice. He did save their Earth, and probably Universe, from Darkseid, so he did his part. He probably deserved to retire, and have a life with Lois, and some… Read more »

December 10, 2019 1:32 pm
Reply to  Randarch

Earth2878, lol I get it Good one Randarch 😀 I’ll be flying around on my earth and stopping Lex and other super villains. 🙂 Maybe they should find my version of Superman and ask for help. Good one Randarch, I like it! 😀 Yeah I agree with you about Tom’s version. I like how they gave him a happy ending with Lois,but with the news of an apocalyptic event coming, I was surprised that he wasn’t all that concerned. Especially since he just told Lex that a life with a family is most important to him, I would think that… Read more »

December 10, 2019 1:40 pm
Reply to  Superman2878

After seeing these recent episodes I have to say, Avengers end what???

December 10, 2019 6:12 pm
Reply to  Superman2878

Earth-2878… I like it! PM me an email address and I’ll have a treatment for you by Monday morning.

December 10, 2019 3:14 pm

Also… and others may have already thought of this… I’ve decided that since Flash90’s Barry is actually another version of Henry Allen… (And isn’t his Jay Garrick?)… That Cryer’s Lex, is actually another version of S4’s Lenny. Follow: In S4, Lex has a nephew, Lenny Luthor. Which means that Lex had a sibling, more than likely a brother. We’ll call him Jullian. So, in S4, Jullian’s son is Lenny. But, let’s say that in the Supergirl TV show Universe (what number are they?) Jullian doesn’t have a brother. He’s an only child. But he has a son, whom he names… Read more »

December 10, 2019 5:04 pm
Reply to  Randarch

Maybe they should ask Lex if he’s ever played drums. Lol 😀

December 10, 2019 5:18 pm

Here’s an idea, they should make a movie where Routh’s Kingdom Come Superman meets Cavill’s Man of Steel Superman. If not, then maybe someone can make a fan film, and edit scenes of both Supermen to have them meet. I know that there’s one where Cavill meets Reeve, so they can pretty much do the same with Routh now that there’s more footage of his Superman. Just a thought. But how about that film idea? I bet it would sell a lot of tickets. And I mean a lot. I’m not a fan of Cavill’s take, but I recognize the… Read more »

December 10, 2019 10:55 pm

Loved everything with Routh even though he’s not *exactly* Kingdom Come Superman but still a Superman who has been through some stuff combined with the Superman of Superman Returns. The Batman stuff with Kevin Conroy I’m less sure about, *He* was great. I guess maybe they sort of took the rise of the anti-hero angle from KC and gave that to the idea of a Batman who completely disappears up his own grimdark to the point where he just becomes a villain which is kinda where the more extreme “badass” versions of Batman who are hyper paranoid and can’t recognize… Read more »