Mild Mannered Reviews – Heroes in Crisis #8

KindleDownload iBookBuy Now

Heroes in Crisis #8 [of 9]

Scheduled to arrive in stores: April 24, 2019
Cover date: June 2019


Writer: Tom King
Artist: Mitch Gerads and Travis Moore
Cover: Mitch Gerads
Variant Covers: Ryan Sook

Reviewed by: Glen J. Clark

Click to enlarge

Heroes in Crisis #8In the confession room, Wally West explains the events that led to the tragedy at Sanctuary. He questions the validity of Sanctuary. Is it an actual place that has helped others or was it invented just for me? He remembers his past life (Pre-New 52) with Linda Park, his wife and their children, all now a past memory. If this place was real, than their must be others here with him, but because the place is anonymous he was not allowed any interactions with others, strengthening his suspicions about being alone even further. So he decides, since he is the fastest man alive, to take all this “deleted” data that has been cracked and put it back together, revealing to him every person who has gone through Sanctuary, the pain they were feeling during their confessionals, the acts that they were trying to sort through in the virtual reality rooms. Piecing this puzzle back together set off some sort or alarm announcing everyone to please exit Sanctuary. Already struggling with his own mental struggles, and now adding everyone else who has been through Sanctuary, is more than Wally could bare and he could not keep his speed force in check, emanating bursts of lightning from his body killing everyone who was outside of Sanctuary. In a panic he ran inside and saw Booster Gold and Harley Quinn had not made it outside, so in a flash he put both back into separate Virtual Reality chambers and programmed each to show the other person killing the other occupants outside. Wally then traveled five days into the future, found and killed his future self and brought it back to the past and laid it beside his friend Roy Harper. Rearranging the crime scene and leaving cryptic notes to throw Batman and Barry Allen off track. All of this to buy him some time, five days to be exact. Five days to try and do something as good as he had done bad. Five days to tell the truth.

To be continued…

4Story – 4: In typical Tom King fashion, this story has been very controversial. Just look at Tom King’s Twitter page and you will know what I am talking about. One person even sent him death threats over this story. So why 4 Shields? Often we as fans get so passionate about our favorite characters that we confuse what is written versus how it is written. This book in particular is brilliantly crafted. As we get an internal look into Wally’s head we see a man struggling to find himself in this world that has basically forgotten him. The book even mentions that everyone said he was the symbol of Hope (see ‘DC Rebirth’), but with Linda, his wife from a previous world, not even recognizing him and his kids nowhere to be seen, he feels anything but Hope, in fact he feels rather hopeless. Which brought him to Sanctuary in the first place. With all of this heartache, and then adding all the pain and memories from everyone who ever stepped foot inside Sanctuary it was just too much, and something he has been able to control all his life, the speed force, erupted from him, killing those around him. Tom King writes a story that deals with the harsh reality of ‘it could happen to anyone’. A parent, a loved one, even a hero can lose control when pushed to the limit. Separate the who done it for why he did it and you will see the brilliance behind this story.

5Art – 5: This book for the most part has been done by the talented Clay Mann, and the visuals have been breathtaking. However, for this particular issue, Mitch Gerads does an exceptional job setting the overall tone that this book was trying to deliver. Every page was simply breathtaking.

5Cover Art – 5: A dichotomy of Wally’s life, what should have been versus what it really is. This cover captures Wally’s perfect day; a husband and a father enjoying the peacefulness of the outdoors with people who love and support him, his wife and kids. If this was a reality, the events that happened in this book would never have happened.

3Variant Cover Art – 3: These covers have been a lot of fun, different events for characters across the DC Universe in the form of a case file showing what brought them to Sanctuary. This one focuses on the transformation of Dr. Harleen Quinzel into Harley Quinn. However just the top of her head coming out of the vat of chemicals just didn’t do much for me. Maybe if it showed more than just the tip of her nose up. Maybe if there was an image of the Clown Prince of Crime in the background, but as it stands this cover is average at best and is outshined by the regular cover.

Check out the Mild Mannered Reviews contents page.

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
April 30, 2019 8:58 am

I think that King at this point has destroyed Wally more than the New52 deleting him from existence.
You can try & defend it all you want, but King has now become Queen and his power of writing has now diminished like a dying star into oblivion.
Heck, you can have Wally go ape berserk on a few random innocents & it would STILL have the same impact but without making Wally into a complete pSyChO by framing the survivors & creating a CSI freakshow.
Know whaddya mean, Vern? 😉

May 4, 2019 12:38 pm
Reply to  DW13

I totally agree. Much to do about nothing. Ridiculous hype. The whole thing was overblown and not necessary.Ruined a great character and one of my favorites.

Super El
April 30, 2019 4:58 pm

This is one of the worst issues King has ever done, along with one of the worst reviews I’ve seen about it. Wally already suffered something similar and he didn’t come out looking like this, but rather as who he’s always been. Same with Superman. You are who you are in the dark, and heroes have faced worse before.

You asking to separate the who from the why is proof enough that this story didn’t work. This is a bad review.

May 4, 2019 12:40 pm
Reply to  Super El

Excellent points. Total agreement.

April 30, 2019 8:21 pm

In some way I actually wish I could say I was shocked that DC took a giant whiz on Wally West.

But at this point I’m not. Not at all.

May 4, 2019 12:40 pm
Reply to  MattComics

Sad, isn’t it Matt.

May 4, 2019 4:44 pm
Reply to  Superman555

Sad doesn’t even begin to cover it really. I mean if we have an editorial regime present at DC Comics that can’t even be bothered to have a basic respect for the fact that a character like Wally West means something to people as a hero then why the hell should we trust them with Clark Kent?

May 1, 2019 12:51 pm

DC should just admit now that their initials stand for the only two things they really care about or understand, being Dark and Cynical.

May 4, 2019 12:41 pm
Reply to  MattComics

Harsh, but kinda hits the spot.