Buy NowDownload

Mild Mannered Reviews - Supergirl Comics

Supergirl #8

Supergirl #8

Scheduled to arrive in stores: April 18, 2012

Cover date: June 2012

"Girl in the World"

Writer: Michael Green and Mike Johnson
Penciller: George Pérez
Inker: Bob Wiacek
Cover: George Pérez

Reviewed by: James Lantz

Click to enlarge

Having defeated the Worldkillers and saved planet Earth, Supergirl now finds herself surrounded by military people pointing weapons at her. Her battle has left her tired even under the yellow sun that has given her all of her superhuman abilities. The Maid of Might does not wish to be in another fight. Unfortunately, none of the soldiers can speak Kryptonian, making it impossible for them to understand Supergirl's intentions. The army is about to attack Kara Zor-El when an Irish girl with white hair named Siobhan Smythe intervenes. The young lady even speaks to Kara in her native language, allowing our heroine to believe that she is from Krypton. However, this doesn't ease the conflict between Supergirl and the armed forces. In spite of Siobhan's efforts to negotiate, things have gone badly. The head of the operation now wants to take both girls into custody. Worse yet, Kara has been forced to defend herself and Siobhan while making a getaway. Bullets and heat vision are fired as Supergirl prepares to leave with her new friend for answers. The Girl of Steel shields Siobhan from the oncoming projectiles, but as the young women take to the skies, air support is called to pursue the feisty female duo. Both Supergirl and Siobhan could get into a mess from which they may not be able to exit if things continue in this manner.

Siobhan has the ability to learn and imitate sounds and languages of every species from what seems to be every world. This is how she could speak to Kara in Kryptonian so easily like a native. In the meantime, Kara is confused. She has lost her home and family and has found herself on an alien planet. Knowing that her super-powered friend will need a place to live, Siobhan offers to let Supergirl stay with her. However, before more arrangements can be made, the girls are found by the military. The Maid of Tomorrow attacks the air support forces as they are about to arrest her and the youthful Irish lass. Siobhan must eventually persuade Kara to stop hurting the soldiers. She now realizes that she must keep a low profile. Plus, once she and Siobhan arrive in the apartment in which the young linguist is possibly slumming, Kara discovers something in a television news bulletin. Supergirl has just become Public Enemy Number One. If she doesn't do something about this, she may have difficulty assimilating to life on Earth.

Siobhan and Kara have become kindred spirits of sorts. Both girls lost their family. In fact, Siobhan has rune tattoos on her forearms - an S on the right, and a B on the left. The S stands for "Siobhan", while the B is for her father. Siobhan, being a musician, takes Kara out on the town to her next gig after the Lost Daughter of Krypton changes into civilian clothes. The sounds on the street are overwhelming for Kara as she hears everyone and everything at once. Focusing on Siobhan's voice helps her to calm down and get control of her super hearing somewhat in spite of her still having trouble adapting to all that's been going on lately. Can Siobhan Smythe become Kara Zor-El's first real friend on Earth?

As Siobhan sings a folk song in a club a boy is talking to Kara. Suddenly, his face distorts in a horrifying manner. The same thing happens to everyone else at the gig. Siobhan rushes off the stage to get Kara away from the frightening mob only to be stopped by her dad, who calls himself the Black Banshee. Siobhan has been running from him for quite some time even if he is supposed to be dead. Kara, quick to defend her new friend, uses her powers, especially heat vision, in vain against this new foe whose powers come from magic. The Maid of Might is about to continue her assault on this new malevolent menace as a hand stops her. Siobhan has become the eerie, chalk white Silver Banshee. Only she can stop Black Banshee from bringing his evil plans to take this world's souls to fruition. Supergirl will have her hands full now that she is caught in the middle of a father/daughter conflict of epic proportions.

4Story - 4: The previous numbers in this series have been decent. Yet, they feel like mostly filler material sandwiched between an arc that could have been told in two to three issues at the most. That being said, it was difficult to give Supergirl #8 a proper rating when I first read it. It took a second and third go to eventually make a decision. There is still filler material here and there. However, it is less than what appeared in the books before this one. The story isn't perfect, but this is one of the better issues of the NEW 52's Supergirl for me.

When a character is connected to the hero of a comic book in some way or other, it can be interesting if done well. It can also blow up in a writer's face if executed poorly as it was with the origin of Doctor Octopus in John Byrne's Spider-Man: Chapter One. Fortunately, having Silver Banshee befriending Kara works for the New 52 version of both characters. The fact that Supergirl is caught in the middle of Siobhan's conflict with her father the Black Banshee makes this story arc and the entire series more interesting so far. It also makes Silver Banshee more interesting. I liked her as a villain in the past, but I always felt something was missing. Siobhan is dealt with in a manner that also gives readers a bit of sympathy for her. The Silver and Black Banshees are a highlight in this book that make it more entertaining. Again, this eighth issue isn't without its flaws, but it made me look forward to number nine. Let's hope next month's outing doesn't disappoint.

4Art - 4: There were things I liked and things I didn't in the art for the previous seven issues of this title. This makes me wonder why it wasn't as good as what's on the pages of this one. Granted, the visuals on some pages aren't as good as others due to what looks like an odd inking on the pages where Siobhan talks to pigeons and the military finds her and Kara. Still, it's classic George Pérez. Let's hope we see more of his work in future DC comic books.

5Cover Art - 5: This is an incredible image, and it's everything I'd come to expect from Pérez. It's plain awesome. It does what a cover should always do, make the viewer curious about the material within the comic book's pages. If this shot of Silver Banshee with a trapped Supergirl doesn't make you want to look inside, nothing will.

Mild Mannered Reviews


Note: Month dates are from the issue covers, not the actual date when the comic went on sale.

January 2012

February 2012 March 2012 April 2012 May 2012 June 2012 July 2012 August 2012 September 2012 October 2012 November 2012 December 2012

Back to the Mild Mannered Reviews contents page.

Check out the Comic Index Lists for the complete list of Superman-related comics published in 2012.