“Superman & Lois” Review – S02E13 – “All Is Lost”

All Is Lost

Reviewed by: Michael Bailey

Originally Aired: June 7, 2022
WRITTEN BY: Kristi Korzec
DIRECTED BY: Elaine Mongeon

REGULAR CAST:
Tyler Hoechlin (Clark Kent/Superman)
Bitsie Tulloch (Lois Lane)
Jordan Elsass (Jonathan Kent)
Alex Garfin (Jordan Kent)
Emmanuelle Chriqui (Lana Lang Cushing)
Inde Navarrette (Sarah Cushing)
Wolee Parks (John Henry Irons)
Tayler Buck (Natalie Irons)
Erik Valdez (Kyle Cushing)
Inde Navarrette (Sarah Cortez)

GUEST STARS:
Dylan Walsh (General Sam Lane)
Jena Dewan (Lucy Lane)
Rya Kihlstedt (Ally Alston)
Joselyn Picard (Sophie Cushing)
Stephanie Cho (Erin Wu)

5Rating – 5 (out of 5):

My favorite part of this week’s episode was watching Clark and Sam have very honest conversations with their kids. Maybe I’m getting a little sentimental as I get older but watching two fathers admit the mistakes that they have made, along with Lois having an honest conversation with her sister, is just as important as watching Superman take on and utterly fail to stop Ally. The heart and soul of this series is the various families that make up the cast and the fact that I am more emotionally invested in their relationships than the super-hero stuff says a lot about the great job the writers and actors have done of bringing those relationships to life.

Sam Lane has had one of the best character arcs of both season one and season two. The scenes with him and Lois and Lucy were so well done and, even though Ally trying to kill Sam in order to get Superman to show up was the somewhat cliched way to get Lucy to stop trusting her, enough good will had been generated that it wasn’t a deal breaker. Sam admitting the mistakes he made and taking responsibility for what happened was sweet but Lois and Lucy turning and telling him that at least he stayed, unlike their mother, was even sweeter. Another thing that made that scene work so well were the flashbacks showing how Lucy got under Alley’s thrall. Without seeing where it all started, seeing where it turns doesn’t have as much impact.

Clark talking to Jordan and Jonathan was equally as good, even though things with Jonathan didn’t go as smoothly as Clark wanted it to. Clark’s talk with Jon was raw and honest and it was heartbreaking to see Jonathan thinking he didn’t have a future. The Clark/Jordan scenes worked on a whole other level and finally… FINALLY… Clark decided to step up and train Jordan. The look of sheer joy on Clark’s face when Jordan flew was just as endearing as the two of them talking on the bench in Smallville. Tyler has the ability to project such joy when something cool happens with his kids and we saw a lot of that in this episode along with some humorous expressions, like when Jordan came in a little hot for the landing.

Lana being so harsh with Sarah and then with Jordan was a good way to show the pressure she is feeling over recent events. Instead of being supportive of her daughter she focused on the fact that Sarah was performing in a bar. And not just any bar. The bar where her husband met the woman he committed adultery with. Then there was her conversation with Jordan, which was severe, but it was something that Jordan needed to hear. So, Lana had a lot going on, which made her scene with Kyle and then the dinner they shared with their kids all the more emotional. I continue to be amazed at the fact that these adults choose, for the most part, to actually talk about their feelings instead of being all closed off. It’s refreshing to see.

John and Nat’s scenes were the only part of the episode where I felt that things were slightly dubious, but even then, it ended up working. Getting Nat suited up was not a surprise. If we’re going to see Jordan stepping up in the hero business than seeing Nat do the same works just as well. The fight over the suit they had felt a little contrived but seeing John having trouble destroying Nat’s armor was adorable. It also worked because both John and Nat were needed towards the end of the episode. It’s the weird thing about this show. Just about every time I think I’m having a problem with the plot or the characterization I end up talking myself down of the critical ledge.

The end of the episode was the perfect “everything goes really bad, really fast” sequence. There are two episodes left. There hasn’t been any fat on the story for the entire season. Depowering Superman at the moment that Ally is trying to merge to the two Earths is exactly where I want to be left. This combined with the fact that the writers have stuck the landing time and again has me so excited for the last two episodes. In a season that started with a Doomsday face out and then gave us a great take on Bizarro and then settled on a new take on Parasite the ending has to be huge, and I have no doubt that the next two episodes are going to be explosive.

5 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Superman2878
June 10, 2022 12:14 pm

Spoiler warning! Spoiler warning! Spoiler warning! Ok here I go! This episode was Fantastic! My favorite part was when Clark was teaching his son how to fly. I just love the reaction Clark had when he got all excited about his son flying for the first time. I was cheering for this scene. 🙂 I love the part where Lois says that Superman “is the world’s greatest hero.” I love that. Superman getting the recognition that he deserves. And that Lois said it, just makes it even more special. 🙂 I hope that Clark doesn’t stay powerless for long. Having… Read more »

Last edited 1 year ago by Superman2878
Loganswalk
Loganswalk
June 12, 2022 9:51 am

This one was … okay. I think Clark is being a terrible father to Jonathan and it is getting on my nerves. He was having a heart to heart with him and then just breaks it off to deal with Jordan. I’m surprised how poorly they are handling the Jonathan/Clark relationship. I would be unhappy as well if I was Jonathan. When your kid tells you things are terrible and your response is, basically, “It will be fine” and then you walk away that isnt great. The show focused a lot on the weakest characters on the show (Lucy, Chrissy… Read more »

Superman2878
June 12, 2022 1:49 pm
Reply to  Loganswalk

I’m going to take a guess here, but I think that now that Clark no longer has his powers, he will start seeing from his son John’s perspective more, and spend more time with him. This version of Clark has never been powerless before. So maybe this will give him the opportunity to experience the world the way John and Lois and the rest of the world experiences it, as a vulnerable human. Then maybe Clark will relate more to John and his current issues of being powerless and unable to help when needed.

bhof
bhof
June 14, 2022 11:15 pm

I really liked this episode. The stakes are great, and the season is coming together nicely. I loved seeing Clark with Jordan and Jonathan.

I’d give this a 4/5. The way we got to Ally depowering Superman really bothered me for 3 reasons:

  1. Why would Ally suddenly attack Sam when she’s so carefully manipulated Lucy this whole time?
  2. How could Lucy still call Superman after seeing Ally openly attack Sam?
  3. Why in the world would Superman not survey the situation before rushing right into Ally’s attack? He’s got years of experience.
Superman2878
June 20, 2022 10:46 am
Reply to  bhof

You raise some very interesting questions. I can’t think of an explanation for your first question, but I think that maybe Lucy calling Superman was out of desperation. She had no choice but to call for Superman to save her dad from Ally who has now become a monstrous parasite super-being. As for Superman not surveying the situation before acting, I think he was so concerned for Lois’s safety that he didn’t really give enough time to think about how to save his wife and think of a plan stop Ally. I think his reaction was instinctual. Where he would… Read more »