Review – “Justice League vs. The Fatal Five” Animated Movie

Digital Release: March 30, 2019
Physical Release: April 16, 2019

WRITTEN BY: Eric Carrasco, Jim Krieg and Alan Burnett

Elyes Gabel as Thomas Kallor/Star Boy
Diane Guerrero as Jessica Cruz/Green Lantern
Kevin Conroy as Batman
Susan Eisenberg as Wonder Woman
George Newbern as Superman
Peter Jessop as Tharok
Matthew Yang King as The Persuader
Sumalee Montano as Emerald Empress
Philip Anthony Rodriguez as Mano
[Validus does not speak]

Reviewed by: Steve Younis

4Rating – 4/5: When it was first announced, “Justice League vs. The Fatal Five” wasn’t necessarily and animated movie that sounded enticing to me. I wasn’t that familiar with the Fatal Five to be honest, and another “vs.” movie (after “Justice League vs. The Teen Titans”) wasn’t that appealing. It wasn’t until I saw that this movie’s character designs were based on the “Justice League”/”Justice League Unlimited” animated series, with the same voice cast returning, that my interest levels were raised considerably.

As the blurb states, “Justice League vs. The Fatal Five” finds the Earth’s future hanging in the balance when the Justice League faces a powerful new threat – the Fatal Five. Superman, Batman and Wonder Woman seek answers as the time-traveling trio of Mano, Persuader and Tharok terrorize Metropolis in search of budding Green Lantern, Jessica Cruz – whom they need to free remaining Fatal Five members Emerald Empress and Validus in order to carry out their sinister plan. But the Justice League discover an ally from another time in the peculiar Star Boy – brimming with volatile power.

This animated film finds the right balance between action, drama, emotion and humor. It really is a story about Jessica Cruz and Star Boy more than anything else, but the other heroes, especially Superman, do get a fair share of the limelight (no pun intended).

The themes in this story are quite mature. Jessica’s battle with her own mental health issues bring her together with Star Boy, who is himself dealing with his own mental problems. Her understanding of what he’s going through, even though he’s from a far-flung future, allows her to build a bond with him that sees Star Boy find his feet in a world/time that has no idea who he is or what he’s capable of.

While Wonder Woman takes a “tough love” approach towards Jessica, you can see that she believes in her and just wants her to believe in herself as well. Superman takes a softer approach (as you’d expect), while Batman’s dismissiveness actually makes for a really nice dynamic between them. Actually Batman’s relationship with Miss Martian, who is also a welcome addition to the story, is a highlight of this animated movie.

Miss Martian’s inclusion brings some comic relief to the weighty topics of the story. Her quips, one-liners, and banter with Batman help the story in a way that The Flash did in the JL/JLU animated episodes. (Interestingly, The Flash, Jon Stewart, Martian Manhunter and other members of the JLU only appear in statue form in this movie when we’re taken of a tour of a 31st century museum).

Speaking of the 31st century, while Star Boy is a member of the Legion of Superheroes, we only see his teen teammates at the beginning and end of the story. Most of the film takes place in the 21st century, with the villains having travelled back in time to kidnap Jessica Cruz.

The adventure does take us to a number of locations, with some of the battle taking place on Oa. Seeing other members of the Green Lantern corps was a welcome addition, and really helped us learn more about who Jessica Cruz is, while allowing her to discover more about herself at the same time.

Superman’s involvement, especially in the final moments, are heroic. I was pleased with how he was portrayed. However, this is very much a story about Jessica Cruz and Star Boy, so while he’s important to the story, he’s not the main focus… and I was fine with that. Same goes for Batman and Wonder Woman. They’re each given moments to shine, but they never take away from the main focus of the story.

All in all I’d rate this animated movie a 4/5. Well worth watching.

The bonus material on the Blu-ray includes some great interviews with the creative people behind the film, at DC Comics and in the field of mental health. They’re fascinating to watch and well produced.

Produced by Warner Bros. Animation and DC Entertainment, the feature-length animated Justice League vs. The Fatal Five is available on 4K Ultra HD Combo Pack and Blu-ray Combo Pack.

Tell your friends
  • 29
  • 1
  • 4
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
April 25, 2019 9:27 pm

I just saw this movie today on the DCU App, and I LOVED it! A great mix of new and old characters. Actual substance in the plot. Great storytelling.

So much better than the recent Animated DVD’s that have come out from DC. You can really tell the creative team here are all grandmasters. I’m dying for a new season of JLU!

April 25, 2019 11:11 pm

The most impressive thing about this movie was how effortlessly it fit with JLU. Even beyond the throwbacks and audio cues/music, it just plays out like a longer episode of JL/JLU and for those of us who watched the show way back when, we should feel right at home. I have some “notes” about some questionable logic and I also expected a little bit more of Jessica. She’s technically the center piece, but arguably Thom steals the show. Also, it was nice to see animation that’s competent again. It has been a long while since the last time I didn’t… Read more »

April 26, 2019 6:13 am

I also saw it on the DCU app…. I thought it was ok. more 3 out of 5… I really feel that the JL should not be taking a back seat to introduce some newcomers… that’s more for a Young Justice/Teen Titans movie. The JL are the best of the best…and this was the trinity… also really hate when they mess with comics history. The Legion was created because of Superman’s legacy… and the movie totally left that out and turned it into the JL legacy. On the DCU app they have the Legion Of Superheroes cartoon that gets the… Read more »

May 19, 2019 1:14 pm

Saw this last night and thought it was excellent and done well. It was sort if a mix of old and new. I give it a strong B+! If you stayed around long enough(during credits) you would have heard a version of the original JL theme song. That was great as well! Superman was used appropriately without being abused. As I said, done well and done without creating statement baggage. Could watch again.