Superman Comic Books

The SHIELD Awards

The Superman Homepage Indicator of Excellence in Literature and Design Awards


The voting booth for our 16th annual awards ceremony for the world of Superman has closed!

Voting began on November 9, 2016 and ended at 11.59pm on December 7, 2016.

Prize The 2016 SHIELD Awards gave you, the fans, the opportunity to voice your opinions about comics with a 2016 cover date, Superman related Movies, TV shows, and Superman merchandise released in 2016.

Everyone who voted in the 2016 SHIELD Awards automatically went into the draw for a chance to win a prize pack consisting of "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice" Ultimate Cut on Blu-ray and "Supergirl: The Complete First Season" on DVD.

There could only be one winner and that person is: Michael Ho

The results have been forwarded on to DC Comics, Warner Bros., The CW, and the various winners. Congratulations to those creative people involved!

Here are the results...

2016 SHIELD Award Winners

BEST COMIC BOOK WRITER

For the second year running Dan Jurgens takes out the Best Comic Book Writer category for his work on "Superman: Lois and Clark" and "Action Comics".

Dan Jurgens (Superman: Lois and Clark, Action Comics) 37%
Peter J. Tomasi & Patrick Gleason (Superman, Batman/Superman, Superman/Wonder Woman) 15%
Geoff Johns (Justice League) 14%
Max Landis (Superman: American Alien) 12%
Sterling Gates (Adventures of Supergirl) 6%
Brian Buccellato (Injustice: Gods Among Us) 4%
Greg Pak and Aaron Kuder (Action Comics) 3%
Phil Jimenez (Superwoman) 2%
Francis Manapul (Trinity) 2%
Gene Luen Yang (Superman, New Super-Man) 2%
Neal Adams (Coming of the Supermen) 2%
Bryan Hitch (JLA, Justice League) 1%
Dan Abnett (Earth 2: Society) 0%
Steve Orlando (Supergirl) 0%

BEST COMIC BOOK ARTISTS (Penciller/Inker team)

Working together on "Action Comics", this year's Best Comic Book Artists are Stephen Segovia/Art Thibert, who just edged out the team of Lee Weeks/Scott Hanna on "Superman: Lois and Clark". No surprise they're both Dan Jurgens written titles.

Stephen Segovia/Art Thibert (Action Comics) 13%
Lee Weeks/Scott Hanna (Superman: Lois and Clark) 12%
Francis Manapul (Trinity) 9%
Jason Fabok (Justice League) 8%
Doug Mahnke/Jaime Mendoza (Superman, Batman/Superman, Superman/Wonder Woman) 7%
Neal Adams (Superman: Coming of the Supermen) 7%
Patrick Gleason/Mick Gray (Superman) 7%
Aaron Kuder (Action Comics) 6%
Patrick Zircher (Action Comics) 6%
Mike S. Miller (Injustice: Gods Among Us) 5%
Brian Ching/Ray McCarthy (Supergirl) 4%
Mikel Janin (Superman) 4%
Phil Jimenez/Matt Santorelli (Superwoman) 4%
Marco Santucci (Injustice: Gods Among Us) 3%
Bryan Hitch/Daniel Henriques (Justice League of America) 2%
Howard Porter (Superman) 2%
Tom Derenick (Injustice: Gods Among Us) 1%
Tony S. Daniel/Sandu Florea (Justice League) 1%
Bruno Redondo/Angel Hernandez (Earth 2: Society) 1%
Jesus Merino/Andy Owens (Justice League) 1%
Viktor Bogdanovic/Richard Friend (New Super-Man) 1%
Xermanico (Injustice: Gods Among Us) 0%

BEST REGULAR SUPERMAN TITLE

Interestingly, "Action Comics" was beaten out by "Superman" this year, with the Rebirth era definitely a winner with the fans.

Superman (Rebirth) 43%
Action Comics (Rebirth) 40%
Action Comics (New 52) 7%
Superman (New 52) 5%
Superman/Wonder Woman 3%
Batman/Superman 2%

BEST SUPERMAN FAMILY BOOK (i.e. Other Superman-family comics)

It was no surprise, with Dan Jurgens once again winning the Best Comic Book Writer category, to see the conclusion to his "Superman: Lois and Clark" comic book miniseries once again the winner in this category by a large margin.

Superman: Lois and Clark 40%
Trinity 13%
Justice League 11%
Supergirl 11%
Injustice: Gods Among Us 7%
Superwoman 7%
New Super-Man 6%
Justice League of America 3%
Earth 2: Society 2%

BEST ONE SHOT, LIMITED SERIES, OR GUEST APPEARANCE (i.e. Other Superman-related comics)

The "Rebirth" of the DC Universe was clearly a winner with the fans... but the Max Landis written "American Alien" wasn't far behind.

Rebirth [Various Issues] 26%
Superman: American Alien [7-parts] 21%
Justice League - Darkseid War [Various Issues] 15%
Adventures of Supergirl [13-parts] 14%
Batman v Superman Prequel [5-chapters] 8%
Superman: Coming of the Supermen [6-parts] 7%
Aquaman #6 3%
Red Hood & The Outlaws #3 4%
Suicide Squad #2 2%
Red Hood & The Outlaws #2 0%
Suicide Squad #4 0%

BEST STORY/STORY ARC IN THE REGULAR SUPERMAN TITLES

Superman and his young son Jonathan are winning the hearts and minds of Superman fans, with the "Son of Superman" taking top spot in this category ahead of the excellent "The Final Days of Superman" 8-part story.

Son of Superman [6-parts] (Superman) 38%
The Final Days of Superman [8-parts] (Main Superman Books) 22%
Path of Doom [6-parts] (Action Comics) 11%
Superman Meet Clark Kent [2-parts] (Action Comics) 10%
Lois Lane, Back at the Planet [2-parts] (Action Comics) 9%
Escape from Dinosaur Island [2-parts] (Superman) 8%
Universe's Finest [3-parts] (Batman/Superman) 2%

BEST STORY/STORY-ARC IN A SUPERMAN FAMILY/RELATED TITLE

"Justice League" took the No. 1 position in this category again this year, with the conclusion to the "Darkseid War" story voted as the Best Story/Story-Arc in a Superman Family/Related Title for 2016.

Darkseid War [9-parts] (Justice League) 31%
Better Together [2-parts] (Trinity) 16%
Who Killed Superwoman? [3-parts] (Superwoman) 13%
Reign of the Cyborg Supermen [2-parts] (Supergirl) 12%
Made in China [4-parts] (New Super-Man) 8%
After Death [2-parts] (Justice League) 6%
Gods of Justice [2-parts] (Justice League) 4%
Power and Glory [8-parts] (Justice League of America) 4%
A Whole New World [4-parts] (Earth 2: Society) 2%
State of Fear [2-parts] (Justice League) 2%
The Extinction Machines [5-parts] (Justice League) 2%
One Nation Indivisible [5-parts] (Earth 2: Society) 0%

BEST COMIC BOOK COVER

DC Universe: Rebirth #1 Gary Frank's cover for "DC Universe: Rebirth #1" was the fan favorite comic book cover in 2016, just edging out Ryan Sook's cover for "Superman: American Alien #7".

DC Universe: Rebirth #1 9%
Superman: American Alien #7 8%
Trinity #1 8%
Superman: Lois and Clark #8 6%
Action Comics #961 (Variant Cover) 5%
Superman: Rebirth #1 (Variant Cover) 5%
Action Comics #957 (Variant Cover) 5%
Action Comics #966 5%
Supergirl #2 (Variant Cover) 5%
Action Comics #959 4%
Superman #8 4%
Superman: Lois and Clark #3 4%
Action Comics #964 3%
Superman: Coming of the Supermen #1 3%
Action Comics #961 3%
Action Comics #52 2%
Superman #52 (Variant Cover) 2%
Superman/Wonder Woman Annual #2 2%
Action Comics #960 (Variant Cover) 2%
Action Comics #964 (Variant Cover) 2%
DC Universe: Rebirth #1 (Variant Cover) 2%
Injustice: Year Five - Chapter #27-28 2%
Justice League #4 2%
Trinity #2 2%
Action Comics #962 (Variant Cover) 1%
Action Comics #963 (Variant Cover) 1%
Justice League #47 1%
Superman #6 (Variant Cover) 1%
Superman: Coming of the Supermen #1 (Variant Cover) 1%
Action Comics #958 (Variant Cover) 1%
Action Comics #966 (Variant Cover) 1%
Injustice: Year Five - Chapter #17-18 1%
Justice League #46 1%
Justice League of America #5 1%
Justice League of America #9 (Variant Cover) 1%
Superman #49 (Variant Cover) 1%
Superman #5 (Variant Cover) 1%
Superman #6 1%
Superman/Wonder Woman #25 (Variant Cover) 1%

BEST REPRINT/TRADE PAPERBACK

Superman: Lois and Clark TP I guess it's no real surprise that the collected edition of the complete run of Dan Jurgens' "Superman: Lois and Clark" would win in this category.

Superman: Lois and Clark TP 13%
Superman: American Alien HC 7%
Superman: Doomsday TP 6%
Superman: The Man of Steel Vol. 9 TP 6%
Superman Unchained TP 5%
DC: The New Frontier TP 5%
Injustice: Gods Among Us - Year One: The Complete Collection TP 4%
Smallville Season 11 Vol. 8: Chaos TP 4%
Superman: The Final Days of Superman HC 4%
Adventures of Supergirl TP 3%
Batman/Superman/Wonder Woman: Trinity Deluxe Edition HC 3%
Supergirl Vol. 2: Breaking The Chain TP 3%
Superman: The Golden Age Vol. 1 TP 3%
Batman vs. Superman TP 2%
Justice League: Gods and Monsters HC 2%
Superman: Doomed TP 2%
Superman: Emperor Joker TP 2%
Superman: The Golden Age Omnibus Vol. 2 HC 2%
Batman and Superman in World's Finest Silver Age Omnibus Vol. 1 HC 2%
Bizarro TP 2%
Convergence TP 2%
Infinite Crisis: Fight For The Multiverse Vol. 2 TP 2%
Justice League of America Silver Age Omnibus Vol. 2 HC 2%
Supergirl: The Silver Age Omnibus HC 2%
Superman Adventures Vol. 2 TP 2%
Superman: Savage Dawn HC 2%
The Daring New Adventures of Supergirl Vol. 1 TP 2%
Batman/Superman Vol. 3: Second Chance TP 1%
Injustice: Gods Among Us - Year Three Vol. 1 TP 1%
Lex Luthor: A Celebration of 75 Years 1%
Superman/Wonder Woman Vol. 5: A Savage End HC 1%
World's Funnest TP 1%
DC Elseworlds: Justice League Vol. 1 TP 1%
Injustice: Gods Among Us - Year Four Vol. 1 TP 1%
Injustice: Gods Among Us - Year Four Vol. 2 HC 1%
Supergirl Book One TP 1%
Superman Vol. 1: Before Truth TP 1%
Superman Vol. 2: Return To Glory HC 1%
Superman: Action Comics Vol. 6: Superdoom TP 1%
Superman: Action Comics Vol. 8: Truth HC 1%
Superman: Action Comics Vol. 9: Last Rites HC 1%
Superman: The Men of Tomorrow TP 1%
Superman/Batman Vol. 4 TP 1%

BEST APPEARANCE IN AN ALTERNATIVE MEDIA (i.e. TV, Books, Movies, etc...)

Supergirl Now in its second season, the "Supergirl" TV series (and its star Melissa Benoist) continue to win the hearts of Superman fans, staying on top spot in this category ahead of the movie "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice".

Supergirl [TV] 53%
Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice [Movie] 36%
Justice League vs. Teen Titans [Animated Movie] 6%
LEGO DC Comics Super Heroes: Justice League: Cosmic Clash [Animated Movie] 2%
Lois Lane: Double Down [Book] 2%
LEGO DC Super Heroes: Justice League: Gotham City Breakout [Animated Movie] 1%

BEST PRODUCT (i.e. Toys, Statues, Calendar, etc)

Superman Lois Lane Rescue Fleischer Statue The classic 1940s Fleischer Cartoon statue of Superman rescuing Lois Lane just beat out the Supergirl TV statue for Best Product in 2016.

Superman Lois Lane Rescue Fleischer Statue 12%
Supergirl (TV) Supergirl Statue 11%
DC Collectibles: "Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice" Superman Statue 9%
DC Designer Series: Superman and Lois Lane By Gary Frank Statue 8%
Kotobukiya "Batman v Superman" ArtFX+ Superman Statue 7%
Funko Pop! Heroes Clark Kent Figure 7%
Justice League Trinity Premium Art Print 4%
Mattel "Batman v Superman" Action Figures 4%
DC Comics Bombshells: Supergirl Bust 4%
DC Films Premium Action Figures: Armored Batman and Superman 4%
Sideshow Collectibles Lex Luthor in Power Suit Premium Format Figure 3%
DC Comics Icons Lex Luthor Statue 3%
DC Films: Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice Lex Luthor and Wonder Woman Action Figures 3%
Mezco One:12 Collective Classic Superman Figure 3%
New 52 Superman 1:6th Scale Limited Edition Statue 3%
Prime 1 Studio "Batman v Superman" Superman Figure 3%
Kotobukiya Clark Kent "Truth" ARTFX+ SDCC Statue 2%
Sideshow Collectibles Supergirl Premium Format Figure 2%
Superman vs Lex Luthor Premium Art Print 2%
DC Comics Bombshells: Power Girl and Superman Statue 2%
Funko SDCC Exclusive "Batman v Superman" Doomsday Figure 2%
Mezco One:12 Collective "Red Son" Superman Figure 2%
Funko SDCC Exclusive Superman "False God" Variant Figure 1%
Mezco One:12 Collective "Batman v Superman" Figure 1%
Iron Studios "Batman v Superman" Superman Statue 1%
Mighty Jaxx XXRAY Superman Figure 1%
Play Arts KAI Black & White Superman Figure 1%
Stanley Lau's Supergirl Premium Art Print 1%

BEST "SUPERGIRL" EPISODE

The premiere of Season 2 of "Supergirl", titled "The Adventures of Supergirl", not only saw the show move to its new home on The CW, but it also saw the introduction of Tyler Hoechlin as Superman... which obviously made it a clear winner amongst the fans.

The Adventures of Supergirl (Season 2, Episode 1) 29%
The Last Children of Krypton (Season 2, Episode 2) 22%
Worlds Finest (Season 1, Episode 18) 11%
Pilot (Season 1, Episode 1) 9%
Manhunter (Season 1, Episode 17) 4%
Survivors (Season 2, Episode 4) 4%
For The Girl Who Has Everything (Season 1, Episode 13) 4%
Human For A Day (Season 1, Episode 7) 3%
Welcome to Earth (Season 2, Episode 3) 3%
Bizarro (Season 1, Episode 12) 2%
Falling (Season 1, Episode 16) 2%
Livewire (Season 1, Episode 5) 2%
Childish Things (Season 1, Episode 10) 1%
Red Faced (Season 1, Episode 6) 1%
Solitude (Season 1, Episode 15) 1%
Better Angels (Season 1, Episode 20) 1%
Blood Bonds (Season 1, Episode 9) 1%
Hostile Takeover (Season 1, Episode 8) 1%
How Does She Do It? (Season 1, Episode 4) 1%
Myriad (Season 1, Episode 19) 1%
Stronger Together (Season 1, Episode 2) 1%
Truth, Justice and the American Way (Season 1, Episode 14) 1%

BEST "SUPERGIRL" WRITER

This was a tight race, with Greg Berlanti taking top spot ahead of Andrew Kreisberg for Best "Supergirl" Writer.

Greg Berlanti (Pilot, The Adventures of Supergirl, Stronger Together) 31%
Andrew Kreisberg (Pilot, The Adventures of Supergirl, Stronger Together, Better Angels, For The Girl Who Has Everything) 26%
Caitlin Parrish (Hostile Takeover, Livewire, Myriad, Strange Visitor From Another Planet, The Last Children of Krypton) 9%
Robert Rovner (Falling, The Last Children of Krypton) 9%
Roberto Aguirre-Sacasa (Bizarro, Hostile Takeover, Livewire) 4%
Michael Grassi (Red Faced, Fight or Flight, Strange Visitor From Another Planet, Truth, Justice and the American Way) 4%
Ted Sullivan (Blood Bonds, Human for a Day, How Does She Do It?) 4%
Yahlin Chang (Childish Things, Human for a Day, How Does She Do It?, Myriad) 4%
Ali Adler (Pilot, Better Angels) 3%
Jessica Queller (Falling, Welcome to Earth) 3%
Derek Simon (Blood Bonds, Welcome to Earth, Manhunter) 2%
Rachel Shukert (Bizarro, Red Faced, Fight or Flight, Solitude) 1%

BEST "SUPERGIRL" ACTOR/REGULAR CHARACTER

It's little surprise to see Melissa Benoist take out the Best "Supergirl" Actor category. It is interesting to see that Calista Flockhart came in at second spot, ahead of David Harewood. No love for Mehcad Brooks as James Olsen.

Melissa Benoist (Kara Danvers/Supergirl) 66%
Calista Flockhart (Cat Grant) 13%
David Harewood (Hank Henshaw/J'onn J'onzz) 10%
Jeremy Jordan (Winslow "Winn" Schott) 4%
Chyler Leigh (Alex Danvers) 3%
Chris Wood (Mon-El) 2%
Ian Gomez (Snapper Carr) 1%
Mehcad Brooks (James Olsen) 1%

BEST "SUPERGIRL" SUPPORTING CAST MEMBER/GUEST APPEARANCE

Once again, being a Superman fan site, it's no surprise to see that Superman (played by Tyler Hoechlin) would be the choice for Best Supporting Cast Member on "Supergirl". He was followed by two previous Super actors in Dean Cain and Laura Vandvervoort.

Tyler Hoechlin (Clark Kent/Superman) 63%
Dean Cain (Dr. Jeremiah Danvers) 11%
Laura Vandervoort (Indigo) 5%
Peter Facinelli (Maxwell Lord) 5%
Laura Benanti (Alura/Astra) 4%
Maggie Sawyer (Floriana Lima) 3%
Sharon Leal (M'gann M'orzz/Miss Martian) 3%
Helen Slater (Dr. Eliza Danvers) 2%
Katie McGrath (Lena Luthor) 2%
Jenna Dewan-Tatum (Lucy Lane) 2%
Glenn Morshower (General Sam Lane) 0%
Chris Vance (Non) 0%



That concludes the SHIELD Awards for 2016. We look forward to a great 2017 and another SHIELD Awards ceremony in a year's time. Thank you all for your participation.