______________________________________________________________ T H E K R Y P T O N I A N C Y B E R N E T Issue #18 -- October 1995 ______________________________________________________________ CONTENTS -------- Section 1: Superscripts: Notes from the Editor News and Notes DC Versus Marvel! The comic event you thought you'd never see! With a Little Help From My Friends... Lois Lane, by Denes House Section 2: Just the FAQs What cities have their own Special Crimes Units? by David T. Chappell And Who Disguised As... A Job for a Real Superman, by J.D. Rummel Not a Fleischer Cartoon "Super Rabbit," by Neil A. Ottenstein Coming Attractions Now that the "Trial" is over, what does December have in store for the Man of Steel? Section 3: Reviews: The "Triangle" Titles Action Comics #715, by William J. Nixon Superman: The Man of Steel #50, by Arthur LaMarche Superman #106, by Ken McKee and Arthur LaMarche Adventures of Superman #529, by Anatole Wilson Section 4: Reviews: Other Super-Titles Superboy #21, by Victor Chan Steel #21, by Dick Sidbury Showcase '95 #10, by Rene' Gobeyn Showcase '95 #11, by Rene' Gobeyn The New Titans #127, by Rene' Gobeyn Section 5: Reviews: Annuals, Specials, and Crossovers Action Comics Annual #7, by William J. Nixon Superboy Annual #2, by Matt Combes Superman: At Earth's End, by Rene' Gobeyn Legion of Super-Heroes #74, by Victor Chan Legionnaires #31, by Victor Chan Section 6: Looking Back: The Phantom Zone "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow?" Part 1: Superman #423, by Jenny Stosser The Silver Age Superman Superman-Red and Superman-Blue, by Bill Morse Brave and the Bold #150 by Joe Crowe Section 7: Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman Sigh-Fi Lois and Clark and romantic sci-fi, by Zoomway Episode Review #3-01: "We Have A Lot To Talk About" The Season Premiere, by Marta Olson The Mailbag An addendum to J.D. Rummel's review last month of "Superman From the 30's to the 70's." EDITORIAL STAFF: --------------- Jeffery D. Sykes, Editor-in-Chief Arthur E. LaMarche, Executive Editor of Reviews LEGAL DISCLAIMERS: ----------------- Superman and all related characters, locations, and events are copyright and trademark DC Comics. Use of the aforementioned is not intended to challenge said ownership. We strongly suggest that each reader look to the media sources mentioned within for further infor- mation. Opinions presented within this issue belong to the authors of the articles which contain them. They should in no way be construed as those of any other particular member of the editorial or contributing staff, unless otherwise indicated. This magazine should be distributed freely via e-mail. Should you desire to share this publication with other on-line services, please contact me at sykes@ms.uky.edu for permission. Feel free to advertise subscription information on other on-line services which have internet mail availability. THE KRYPTONIAN CYBERNET is available by e-mail -- to subscribe, send the commands subscribe kc
end in the body of an e-mail message to "lists@phoenix.creighton.edu" (without the quotation marks). Replace the
field with your INTERNET e-mail address. The program ignores the subject line of the message. Back issues are available via ftp at acm-ftp.creighton.edu and at ftp.hiof.no. Archives are also reachable via the Kryptonian Cybernet Homepage (http://www.ms.uky.edu/~sykes/kc). ______________________________________________________________ SUPERSCRIPTS: Notes from the Editor ------------------------------------ NEWS AND NOTES: DC VS MARVEL/MARVEL VS DC For the full details of this Earth-shattering meeting, see the feature article printed below. But we've got another little point of interest to pass along. First, the GREEN LANTERN/SILVER SURFER crossover which is scheduled to ship in November is now rumored to hint at the massive meeting which follows in December. Also, according to other rumors, the results of this massive conflict will not go unnoticed in either company's universe. After-effects of the miniseries' events will continue to affect each universe in the months following the conclusion of the crossover. Rumor even has it that one character from each universe will be PERMANENTLY transplanted to the other! THE BOY OF STEEL MEETS THE BOY WONDER According to the latest CSNsider, DC has a meeting between Superboy and Robin in the works for early 1996! KC SUBSCRIPTION COUNT Just a quick note to let you know that we recently passed the 1200 subscriber mark! Thanks to each of you for helping make KC such a success! KC RESOURCES Beginning with this issue, the KC Resources section is going permanently AWOL from the magazine. When it has been included in the past, it has actually only been an update, and I've decided that I'm going to cease inclusion of even that. But for those of you who use it, don't worry! I'm not scrapping the KC Resources Index. It will take up permanent residence in the KC Homepage as of the next update, and a text version of the most recent update will always be available at the archive sites for KC. I simply won't be printing it in the issues themselves... THE 1995 KAYCEES! We're almost at the end of the comic year, so that means the Kaycees will be upon us. We'll be printing the voting ballot in next month's issue, along with a recap of what Superman family comics were published with a 1995 cover date. In addition, I will make this 1995 comic index available on the web page, and I hope to facilitate the voting process by setting up a "voting booth" at the homepage, as well. (In fact, if anyone out there has some experience with html forms, I will probably need some assistance in setting this up!) Start thinking about what were the best and worst aspects of the Superman comics in this past year! As always, enjoy the new issue, and I'll see you back here in another month! Jeff Sykes Editor, The Kryptonian Cybernet ______________________________________________________________ DC VERSUS MARVEL! ----------------- Reprinted from COMING COMICS, as printed in PREVIEWS They meet...at last! And YOU decide the outcome! The battle readers have asked for and dreamed about, wished for and speculated upon, demanded but never expected, finally happens as Marvel and DC rock the comics industry with possibly the biggest event in its history. DC VERSUS MARVEL (from DC Comics) and MARVEL VERSUS DC (from Marvel Comics) is the first all-out, full-scale, total blowout meeting of the DC and Marvel Universes -- a cosmic tale of worlds colliding, realities intertwining, and heroes clashing across a dozen fronts! And because comics readers of all ages have for decades argued "Who would win?", Marvel and DC are making sure every reader can be part of the excitement, providing comic-book specialty stores with the means for the general public to determine the outcome of this explosive rivalry. DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC is a 4-issue copublished miniseries in which two estranged entities conflict when the fragile wall separating their realities fractures. In the first two issues, as heroes and villains cross over from each dimension into the other, the celestial beings begin a strange and deadly cosmic chess game to determine whose universe is more powerful -- and essential. Pitting their living pawns against each other in contests of wills and power, the entities bring about battles that readers always believed were impossible: FLASH vs. QUICKSILVER! THOR vs. SHAZAM! ROBIN vs. JUBILEE! SUB-MARINER vs. AQUAMAN! GREEN LANTERN vs. SILVER SURFER! ELEKTRA vs. CATWOMAN! Following a tense series of shattering preliminary bouts between these champions and others, the pivotal battles are fought in issue #3, where the major stars of each universe clash in the Main Event: BATMAN vs. CAPTAIN AMERICA! HULK vs. SUPERMAN! SUPERBOY vs. SPIDER-MAN! WOLVERINE vs. LOBO! WONDER WOMAN vs. STORM! But the outcome of these five fights is left for YOU to decide, as readers vote in advance of issue #3 for the winner of each of the five battles! Every comic-book specialty store will become a polling place for the Main Event, using promotional tools supplied by DC and Marvel. These decisive showdowns -- and the unbelievable, mind-blowing events that follow -- are certain to be the talk of the comics industry for years to come. Each issue of DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC features at least thirty-two pages of story, plus backup features such as MARVEL UNIVERSE/DC WHO'S WHO-style pages to bring newcomers up to date on all the important players. Artist Dan Jurgens (SUPERMAN, SPIDER-MAN, ZERO HOUR), one of the pencillers on the miniseries summed up the event this way: "This may be the coolest thing I've ever worked on! It's what my friends and I used to dream about when we were 14, but never believed would actually happen. I called Mike Carlin just to thank him for offering me this gig. It's an incredible amount of fun." The other creative powerhouses assembled to execute this incredible crossover miniseries are writer Ron Marz (GREEN LANTERN/SILVER SURFER) on issues #1 and #3, and writer Peter David (INCREDIBLE HULK, AQUAMAN) on issues #2 and #4. The two art teams of Jurgens and inker Josef Rubinstein (SUPERMAN); and, penciller Claudio Castellini (cover artist of FANTASTIC FOUR UNLIMITED, COSMIC POWERS UNLIMITED) and inker Paul Neary (EXCALIBUR) share the art chores on all four issues. DC VERSUS MARVEL #1 and #4 are offered by DC Comics. MARVEL VERSUS DC #2 and #3 will be offered by Marvel Comics. In addition, SkyBox and Fleer are producing two exciting trading card series that tie into DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC, spotlighting the key participants and events in the miniseries. The first trading card series ships December 13 to coincide with DC VERSUS MARVEL #1; the second is scheduled to ship on February 27. In the first card set, we get Clark Kent's thoughts on what's going on in the Marvel Universe, while Peter Parker brings his perspective to the DC Universe. Featuring exquisite painted art as well as spectacular line art, the full-color trading cards showcase the work of some of the most talented and popular artists in the business, including Julie Bell, John Byrne, Dave Dorman, Joe Jusko, Barry Kitson, Joe Quesada, Darick Robertson, Boris Vallejo, and many others. Plus, DC is offering the DC VERSUS MARVEL RETAIL POSTER, a special oversized, 27" x 40" 4-color poster that captures the essence of this extraordinary event. Illustrated by Jurgens and Rubinstein, the poster features some of the greatest heroes from each universe in the slugfest of the century. The poster ships December 19 and carries a suggested retail price of $7.95 U.S. Marvel will offer a MARVEL VERSUS DC RETAIL POSTER, scheduled to ship February 27. DC Universe Executive Editor Mike Carlin said, "This is it -- every reader's chance to show the world DC's heroes are the coolest, most powerful heroes who've ever walked the Earth!" Marvel Universe Editor-in-Chief Mark Gruenwald replied, "That Mike -- such a kidder! Everyone knows any one Marvel super-hero can beat any three DC super-heroes...and crack better jokes while doing it! Fans will bear me out on this!" DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC SHIPPING SCHEDULE --------------------------------------------------- November 1995: DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC CONSUMER PREVIEW with ballots, plus promotional kit December 12, 1995: DC VERSUS MARVEL #1 solicited by DC Comics SKYBOX/FLEER TRADING CARD SET 1 solicited by SkyBox December 19, 1995: DC VERSUS MARVEL RETAIL POSTER solicited by DC Comics January 16, 1996: MARVEL VERSUS DC #2 solicited by Marvel Comics February 20, 1996: MARVEL VERSUS DC #3 solicited by Marvel Comics February 27, 1996: MARVEL VERSUS DC RETAIL POSTER solicited by Marvel Comics SKYBOX/FLEER TRADING CARD SET 2 solicited by SkyBox March 5, 1996: DC VERSUS MARVEL #4 solicited by DC Comics HOW TO VOTE ----------- Readers vote either at comic-book specialty stores, by e-mail, or online, in each case using official ballots obtained at your local comics shop in: * The DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC CONSUMER PREVIEW * DC VERSUS MARVEL #1 * Every pack of the first set of Fleer/SkyBox trading cards * Issues of selected comic-book and gaming trade magazines For more information on the crossover, cards, and posters, refer to the October issues of PREVIEWS and Marvel Comics' advanced information publication. ______________________________________________________________ "WITH A LITTLE HELP FROM MY FRIENDS..." ======================================== a column about the Supporting Cast in the Superman family of books by Denes House (dhouse@itsmail1.hamilton.edu) Because of the conspicuous absence of this column due to intense work- load last month, I thought I'd reward you all with the supporting cast member you've probably all been hanging onto your chairs in anticipation for. She is perhaps the most significant person in the lives of both Superman and Clark Kent, and perhaps the single most important supporting character historically, in the Superman mythos. That's right, folks - ============================== LOIS LANE a.k.a. "Superman's girlfriend" Historically, Lois Lane has always played an important role in the Superman mythos, regardless of medium. In today's Superman comics, she has reached her greatest significance, and has become absolutely crucial to the survival of the Superman books. In the beginning, Lois Lane served many functions. She was love interest, tormentor, hostage, and colleague. The infamous two-person love triangle was set up, with Clark Kent in love with Lois Lane, Lois Lane in love with Superman, who was utterly inaccessible. When in the 1986 "Man of Steel" miniseries Lana Lang declares that "Superman belongs to the world," she is stating what every pre-Crisis Superman fan knew to the core of their being. There could never be a possibility of reciprocal love between Superman and Lois Lane. Lois' main function, then, was to serve as a continual reminder of what could never be. She loved the hero, and ignored the nice guy. Many adolescents, myself included, identified with the nice guy, yearning for the beautiful girl to realize that there was a hero inside us. Ultimately, though, this fantasy was an empty one. We knew that there was no chance of that for Superman/Clark. We were left frustrated. This situation was the background for all of the Superman stories told up until the Crisis. While Lois was known in the comic book realm as "Superman's girlfriend," we all knew that the only place she would ever be "Superman's wife" was in the ironically so-called "imaginary stories." In our lives, we knew we had more hope of love than Superman. He *had* to keep up the charade, because there were dire consequences if folks found out that Clark Kent and Superman were the same guy. But for us normal Joes, if we were able to break out of our "secret identity," there was hope. If our Lois Lanes ever found out we were *really* Superman in disguise, Oh Happy Day! Interestingly, even near the beginning, this was a possibility even for the Man of Steel. In an early unpublished Siegel/Shuster story, intended to introduce "K-Metal," an early prototype of Kryptonite, Clark Kent is forced to reveal to Lois Lane that he is, in fact, Superman. As he flies off with her in his arms at the end of the story, they remark to each other that she can now be his "confidante," something he says he has always wished for. That story was never published (I only learned about it in the recent book, "DC Comics"), but today one can easily imagine the impact that story might have had on Superman history. The incredible tension and frustration would be gone! Perhaps it is just as well it was never published, because the marvelous history of Superman comics would be much, much different today if it had. In the "Adventures of Superman" television show, the romance angle of the Clark/Lois relationship was downplayed to almost nil. Superman/Clark Kent were more like heroes/mentors/colleagues to Lois, rather than love interests. Still, Lois was essential to the mythos, if only as a perennial hostage for Superman to rescue. However, this weakened Lois' character, making her more annoying than interesting. In the comics, the tension finally became too much, and the writers of Superman decided to recast Lois as a friend and colleague. The romantic tension was gone, and Superman was not so much concerned with saving Lois anymore as he was in combating cosmic menaces and natural disasters. The stories became less interesting, and sales began to slump badly. "Superman: the Movie" re-introduced Lois Lane as romantic as well as professional foil. In the movie, Lois was allowed to ask all the prickly questions we had always wanted her to ask, and in Superman II, the wall of secrecy was finally allowed to break! Even so, Superman had to again isolate himself from Lois, for her good and for the good of humanity. Even in the delightfully tense movies, Superman was condemned to be alone. No confidante for the Man of Steel. Superman belongs to the world. It is significant that the worst Superman movies removed Lois from her traditional, strongest, romantic role. In Superman III, she is all but absent from the film, and in Superman IV, she seems to be going through the motions. The scene that should have been the best, where Lois and Superman double date with Clark and his editor, ends up falling flat. Then came the Crisis, and "Man of Steel." One of the first things John Byrne did in revamping Superman was to restore Lois Lane to top billing as a Superman supporting character. He gave her life, vitality, spunk. Lois was now a professional rival for Clark Kent. Now that the character of Clark Kent was less geeky than before, Lois needed a new reason to distance herself from her hunky colleague. Byrne found that reason in giving Kent the exclusive first interview with Superman. Lois and Clark became rivals, and a new era of romantic tension was born. Byrne set the stage for other writers to take Superman where he'd never been before, real romance and eventually engagement to Lois Lane. By making "Superman" into a role that Clark Kent played, Byrne opened up the doors to a love life for Clark. Readers no longer felt that it was impossible for Clark and Lois to get together. The tension was still there, but the frustration was gone. Before I close, a word must be said about "Lois & Clark: The New Adventures of Superman." To my mind, that show has done a terrific job of telling the viewers just why Lois is so important. In this season's premiere episode, in a scene that brought tears to my eyes, Ma Kent thanked Lois for being the first woman she could talk to about her son. Lois became not only a confidante for Clark, but also for Ma. I had never thought about how lonely the Kents must feel, having to keep such a huge secret. In Lois and Clark's engagement, Superman found what Siegel and Shuster had wanted to give him all along, a confidante. She is now someone he can share his life with. She is a safety-valve, as well as a solid connection to real life. She is no longer just a hostage, but a motivation. She is no longer annoying. Rather, she has grown into one of the most well-rounded supporting characters in the Superman books. ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 1 _________________________________________________________________ JUST THE FAQs More Details about Frequently-Asked Questions about the Man of Steel by David T. Chappell We interrupt the regularly scheduled Frequently-Asked Question of this column to bring you a brief update on Special Crimes Units. Next month I shall get back to the previously promised topic as I discuss the pre-Crisis incarnations of Supergirl (including, but not limited to, Kara Zor-El). Meanwhile, I have instead devoted my energies to updating my Superman FAQ to Version 2.32 and my Superman Comics List to Version 3.30. These and related files can be found at ftp://ftp.hiof.no/pub/Comics/Superman/ as well as on relevant newsgroups (including rec.arts.comics.info). "What cities have their own Special Crimes Units?" In the December 1994 issue of THE KRYPTONIAN CYBERNET (Issue #8b), I introduced the concept of the Special Crimes Unit as I answered the question "What is the Metropolis S.C.U.?" The presence of many super-powered villains led the Metropolis Police Department to establish a special team that had the training and equipment to handle these "special crimes." Following the success of the Metropolis S.C.U., several other cities have established their own Special Crimes Units. When the aforementioned article was originally printed, only Washington, D.C., and Los Angeles had followed Metropolis' lead. In the months since then, other Special Crimes Units have appeared. It is now apparent that Atlanta and New York have joined the growing list. After the flurry of metahuman activity following in Superboy's wake, the Honolulu Police Department is considering establishing an S.C.U. as well. CITY FIRST APPEARANCE Metropolis Washington, D.C. HAWK AND DOVE #4 Los Angeles GREEN LANTERN #55 Atlanta DAMAGE #13 New York GREEN LANTERN #67 Honolulu - in progress - (SUPERBOY) ______________________________________________________________ And Who Disguised As... ---------------------------------- A Column of Opinion by J.D. Rummel (rummel@phoenix.creighton.edu) A Job for A Real Superman. Like many of you, I watched Christopher Reeve being interviewed by Barbara Walters. I'm sure that I am also not alone in my admiration. This guy was handling things that would reduce most of us to jelly. Hell, admiring him is easy. One of my secret terrors, one of the things that makes me close my eyes and jerk away, is the dark night scenario of myself, stuck in a chair, my body reduced to an unfeeling mass akin to cold beef on a hook, effectively a sack containing a stranger's bones and blood with my head glued to it. On the screen before me was a man, once far more active than myself, who was brought down by a mundane accident. Once he lived my fantasy by yanking off his glasses and leaping into the air to save the world. Now he was living my darkest fear. I watched him, and the irony of it was not lost on me. It was the kind of bullshit reverie that our English teachers tell us is the stuff of Judith Krantz and Star Trek novels: "How ironic, once he portrayed the mighty Superman, now he needs a machine to breathe_ In traditional comic books we get off light. We don't really have to suffer or mourn. We know Superman isn't really dead, it's just a marketing trick. We know Batman isn't crippled forever, that some special sequence of events will heal our champion, and return him to his four comic a month habit. After all, no matter what strides comics have made toward realism, they are still entertainment mechanisms designed for making cash. But the man recreated before me in phosphor dots three nights ago was real, the kind of real that causes that jerk away reaction. I jerk away because I know that could be me, and I can't easily explain why it's not. That's not to say I would be as gracious under pressure--I am a great panicking weasel of Olympic proportions--rather, the similarity is that I could be involved in a common accident and left so incapable. When he related the loss of his respirator, when he shared the time he was alone in the dark waiting for someone to restore his breath I felt something, something it took me some time to codify. Ironically, in the way English teachers love, I had to go to Funny Book Land to do so. There is a vintage Bugs Bunny cartoon wherein the bunny is given super powers. He dons a cape, a mild mannered secret identity and he uses his powers to harass a rabbit hunter and his horse. At the story's climax he loses his powers and is about to be trounced by the two characters whose existence he has made miserable. Suddenly Bugs looks at the audience and says, "this looks like a job for a REAL Superman." He steps into a phone booth, and in keeping with the anti-Axis sentiments of the period, steps out in full Marine dress blues, bringing about salutes from his opponents. The obvious point being: Funny book stories are well and good in their place, but there is a real world where serious things happen. Furthermore, one should never rise above the other. [Purely coincidentally, Neil Ottenstein reviews this very same cartoon in his "The Fleischer Cartoons" column this month. See below! --Jeff] That night, when watching Chris Reeve speak honestly about his loss, about his hopes, seeing him rise above his fears--my fears--not grandly or magically, or cinematically with swelling music, but slowly, with real difficulty, one day at a time, I knew I was seeing something greater than a triumph over a renegade scientist, far greater than the saving of the world. This was the greatest deed he could ever perform. I felt: "This looks like a job for a REAL Superman_ And he was doing it. Away. ______________________________________________________________ NOT A FLEISCHER CARTOON: ----------------------- by Neil A. Ottenstein Episode : "Super Rabbit" Released: 4-3-43 Running Time: ~ 8:10 minutes Faster than a speeding bullet More powerful than a locomotive Able to leap the tallest building "Look up there in the sky, it's a bird." "Naw, it ain't no bird, it's a dive bomber." "No, it's Super Rabbit." "Bugs Bunny - the Rabbit of Tomorrow." We first learn the origin of this intrepid character. Professor Canafrazz is experimenting on a super carrot and Bugs Bunny is his experimental rabbit. He gives the carrot to Bugs, who now eats it. Thus, Bugs becomes Super Rabbit. Bugs pulls out a news clipping about a rabbit drive - "Cottontail Smith to rub out all rabbits." He declares, "This looks like a job for Super Rabbit." He does a shadow costume change and appears as Mary and her little lamb. Realizing his mistake, he changes again and comes out in a baggy Super Rabbit costume. He sweeps up a group of super carrots and bids Canafrazz good-bye. He flies by a horse that is walking in the air. The horse is shocked, exclaiming, "A rabbit up here!" Bugs soon discovers that he needs to recharge with another carrot. After doing so, he lands in Deepinaharta, Texas. Loads of rabbits are running out from the town limits and one warns Bugs about Cottontail Smith. Bugs then decides, "I shall assume the disguise of a mild mannered forest creature." He changes in a phone booth, coming out with glasses and hat, hopping around. He soon encounters Smith, who upon realizing that he is a rabbit tells him he's going to "drill you good." Bugs changes back in the booth and Smith fires. Smith is shocked to see that the bullets don't do anything except leave a rabbit-shaped pattern for a few seconds. Bugs suggests he try a cannon. Bugs catches the cannonball and they proceed to play basketball with it. Bugs then make makeshift stands and gets Smith and his horse to cheer for him. The scene switches to Bugs flying in the air. Smith and his horse approach by plane. Bugs stops it hard and Smith and the horse fly out. They don't realize what has happened until the horse points out that they are unsupported in mid-air. The cartoon laws of physics are then obeyed, and they plummet to the ground. Bugs sends the remains of the airplane down as well. Bugs' power is running out. He goes to recharge, but drops his carrots. Without his power, Bugs falls to the ground. On the ground, he sees parts of the carrots leading to Smith and the horse in Super uniforms. Bugs declares, "This looks like a job for a real Superman." He changes in the phone booth and comes out as a U. S. Marine, singing the Marines anthem. They salute him. He tells them, "Sorry fellas, I can't play with you any more. I've got some important work to do." He continues the anthem and follows a sign saying, "To Berlin, Tokyo, and points east." This is a fun war-time cartoon parody of the Fleischer Superman cartoons. The opening credits are very similar to those of the Superman cartoons. The parody of the opening superlatives is one point of fun. Along with the speeding bullet narration we see a cork popping out of a toy gun. What looks closer to "The Little Engine That Could" sways along the tracks to the locomotive phrase. Accompanying the tallest building phrase is Bugs leaping from a building with a look of absolute horror as he comes down face first. When Canafrazz describes his super carrot, he uses many adjectives to show just how super it is. When Bugs talks to Canafrazz, each time he would call him by a different famous scientist name. The costume changes are similar to the changes in the shadows in the Superman cartoons. Becoming a mild-mannered forest creature is another beautiful touch. The cartoon is full of various Bugs gags. The only wartime references are the dive-bomber phrase at the beginning and then the very end of the cartoon, praising the US troops as the real Supermen. The cartoon succeeds on all fronts. Lots of good humor, a well done parody of the Superman cartoons, and just a bit of wartime propaganda. The "Super Rabbit" cartoon may be found on the video collection BUGS AND DAFFY; THE WARTIME CARTOONS from MGM/UA Home Video. ______________________________________________________________ COMING ATTRACTIONS ------------------ A List of Upcoming Comics Featuring The Superman Family of Characters Assembled by Jeffery D. Sykes This monthly section is dedicated to giving you official information concerning which comics you should watch for in the near future in order to keep up with Superman, Superboy, Supergirl, and all the rest of the Superman family of characters. The information which follows is reprinted without permission from Diamond Previews and is in no way meant to serve as a replacement for that magazine. I strongly recommend that each reader find his or her own copy for additional detailed information on the entire DC Universe! Note that Diamond is now the exclusive distributor of DC Comics! Notes: Of note this month is that STEEL and SUPERBOY approach their second anniversaries as Superman begins to pick up the pieces from his ordeal in space ("The Trial of Superman," as if you didn't know...). THE NEW TITANS comes to an end, leaving us wondering what the future holds in store for Supergirl. (Please not the Justice League next! Give her some time to herself!) Only two crossovers this month. First, December brings the beginning of the landmark DC VERSUS MARVEL/MARVEL VERSUS DC miniseries from the two comic giants -- see our feature article for more on this event! In addition, the delayed LEAGUE OF JUSTICE Elseworlds tale concludes this month. 1. List of Titles by Shipping Date: ----------------------------------- Date: Comic title and information: ---- --------------------------- October 3: Action Comics #716 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 4 (of 12) Michelinie, Dwyer, & Rodier $1.95 Underworld Unleashed #2 (of 3) Waid, Porter, & Green 48 pgs, $2.95 October 10: Superboy #22 UNDERWORLD UNLEASHED tie-in K. Kesel, Grummett, & Hazlewood $1.95 Superman: The Man of Steel #51 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 5 (of 12) L. Simonson, Bogdanove, & Janke $1.95 October 17: Doomsday Annual #1 Various Cover by Jurgens & Ordway 56 pgs, $3.95 The New Titans #128 Wolfman, Rosado, & Blyberg $2.25 Superman #107 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 6 (of 12) Jurgens, Frenz, & Rubinstein Cover by Jurgens & Rubinstein $1.95 October 24: Adventures of Superman #530 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 7 (of 12) UNDERWORLD UNLEASHED tie-in K. Kesel, Immonen, & Marzan Jr $1.95 Showcase '95 #12 (of 12) Supergirl Story Charles Moore & Phil Jimenez Cover by Tom Grummett 48 pgs, $2.95 Steel #22 A TRIAL OF SUPERMAN tie-in L. Simonson, Gosier, & Faber $1.95 Superman: The Man of Steel Gallery #1 Various Artists Cover by Kevin Nowlan 32 pgs, $3.50 October 31: Superman: The Man of Tomorrow #3 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 8 (of 12) UNDERWORLD UNLEASHED tie-in Stern, Grummett, & Breeding $1.95 Underworld Unleashed #3 (of 3) Waid, Porter, & Green 48 pgs, $2.95 November 7: Action Comics #717 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 9 (of 12) Michelinie, Dwyer, & Rodier $1.95 Superman/Toyman #1 K. Kesel, Immonen, & von Grawbadger $1.95 November 14: Superboy #23 K. Kesel, Grummett, & Hazlewood $1.95 Superman: The Man of Steel #52 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 10 (of 12) L. Simonson, Bogdanove, & Giordano $1.95 November 21: Green Lantern #70 (Supergirl) Marz, Pelletier, & Tanghal $1.75 The New Titans #129 Wolfman, Rosado, & Blyberg $2.25 Showcase '96 #1 (of 12) Steel and Guy Gardner Beau Smith & Sergio Cariello Metropolis S.C.U. Scott Ciencin Cover by Sergio Cariello 48 pgs, $2.95 Superman #108 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 11 (of 12) Jurgens, Frenz, & Rubinstein $1.95 November 28: Adventures of Superman #531 THE TRIAL OF SUPERMAN: Part 12 (of 12) K. Kesel, Immonen, & Marzan, Jr. $1.95 League of Justice #1 (of 2) Hannigan & Giordano 48 pgs, Prestige Format, $5.95 Steel #23 L. Simonson, Gosier, & Faber $1.95 December 5: Action Comics #718 Michelinie, Dwyer, & Rodier $1.95 December 12: DC Versus Marvel #1 (of 4) Marz, Jurgens & Castellini, Rubinstein & Neary 48 pgs, $3.95 Superboy #24 K. Kesel, Grummett, & Hazlewood $1.95 Superman: The Man of Steel #53 L. Simonson, Bogdanove, & Rodier $1.95 December 19: The New Titans #130 (Final Issue) Wolfman, Rosado, & Blyberg Cover by George Perez $2.25 Showcase '96 #2 (of 12) Steel and Guy Gardner, Part 2 Beau Smith, S. Cariello, Leigh Steel Supporting Cast vs Metallo L. Simonson, Rosado 48 pgs, $2.95 Superman #109 Jurgens, Frenz, & Rubinstein $1.95 December 26: Adventures of Superman #532 K. Kesel, Immonen, & Marzan Jr. $1.95 League of Justice #2 (of 2) Ed Hannigan & Dick Giordano Prestige Format, 48 pgs, $5.95 Steel #24 L. Simonson, Gosier, & Faber $1.95 2. Spoilers: ------------ December 5: ---------- Action Comics #718 Guns blaze as Superman tries to get to the bottom of the mystery of Demolitia, who hits Metropolis with *very* familiar powers -- namely, those of the recently deceased Bloodsport! December 12: ----------- DC Versus Marvel #1 (of 4) Two cosmic beings begin a strange game to decide whose universe is more powerful. Pitting heroes from both universes against each other, the entities bring about battles readers always believed were impossible! (See our feature article for more information on this series!) Superboy #24 Silversword is back and out for vengeance! It's up to Superboy and his new "partner," Knockout, to stop him. Plus, Knockout's past catches up to her... Superman: The Man of Steel #53 A barroom brawl at the Ace of Clubs results in Bibbo getting his big shot in the boxing ring. Plus, eerie apparitions are spotted at the Daily Planet, and Lex Luthor's encounter with the Contessa has a surprising outcome. December 19: ----------- The New Titans #130 (Final Issue) MELTDOWN: The Conclusion -- The Titans gather for their final assault against the Psions, the Gordainians, and Raven! Witness the final fates of the Titans in this explosive series finale, including Changeling, Cyberion, Starfire, Blackfire, Green Lantern, Darkstar, Arsenal, Minion, Terra, and More! Showcase '96 #2 (of 12) Steel and Warrior battle Sledge and the Enforcer in the conclusion of a 2-part story by Beau Smith, with art by Sergio Cariello and Rob Leigh. Meanwhile, the new, more powerful Metallo returns to Washington, D.C., and with Steel occupied, only John Henry's friends can save the city in a story by Louise Simonson, with pencils by William Rosado. Backup story about Ares and Circe by Christopher Priest. Superman #109 Ghost sightings continue at the Daily Planet, but Superman has his hands full with Kill Fee, a crazed killer whose victims are editors. Plus, a long-lost friend of Clark Kent returns. December 26: ----------- Adventures of Superman #532 It's the return of Lori Lemaris, Clark Kent's college flame, whom he believed was long dead. And this time, the mermaid has legs! Plus, life's looking good for Jimmy Olsen as he gets an incredible new girlfriend. League of Justice #2 (of 2) The all-star two-part Elseworlds odyssey concludes: To return home, the teenagers from Earth's dimension must gather the heroes of a magical world against the evil warlord Luthor and the super-warrior who champions his cause. Steel #24 Steel battles Hazard's armored super-soldier and John Henry's life unravels when secrets are exposed that will dramatically alter his career as a hero. ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 2 ______________________________________________________________ REVIEWS ------- Ratings Panelists: AL: Art LaMarche JS: Jeff Sykes RG: Rene Gobeyn AW: Anatole Wilson KM: Ken McKee VC: Victor Chan DS: Dick Sidbury MC: Matt Combes WN: William J Nixon As always, the first rating given after the average is that of the reviewer. THE "TRIANGLE" TITLES: --------------------- 42. ACTION COMICS #715, "Doc Parasite!" Writer: David Michelinie Artists: Gil Kane & Denis Rodier Cover: Kieron Dwyer & Denis Rodier $1.95 US/$2.75 CAN/#1.25 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.5/5.0 Shields WN: 3.0 Shields - Great Kane/Rodier artwork AL: 3.5 Shields - Power Superman back up soon, please! AW: 3.0 Shields - Okay, but just...average. DS: 4.0 Shields - An excellent issue. A brainy Parasite could be the ultimate villain. Watching him lure Superman into a trap was reminiscent of the times when villains used brains as well as brawn to terrorize the world. JS: 4.0 Shields - Nice artwork by Kane and Rodier, and who'd have ever guessed that Superman would be out-THOUGHT by the Parasite!? This issue seamlessly follows on from S:MoT#2 in which Luthor conspired to bring Dr. Torval Freeman and the Parasite together. This was done at the behest of Luthor's new master (Neron). Lex is unhappy with his current situation. The Parasite consumed Freeman but because of tinkering, Freeman's mind remains intact. He hasn't realized he has been absorbed until he looks in the mirror and discovers he's now 'Doc Parasite'. Superman returns to Metropolis, finds the city relatively peaceful and thinks about a relaxing evening. Cool, Clark likes the Marx Brothers and endorses an ice cream for the style-conscious. In S.T.A.R. Labs, Freeman comes to terms with his situation. Rudy Jones, the Parasite, and joint occupier of "his" head brings him up to speed on the melding of minds which has occurred. Jones enlists Freeman's aid, and mind, to help him get more power. They want Superman's energy and set up a crisis which only he can deal with. Next morning, outside S.T.A.R. Labs, Lois and Jimmy meet as rivals covering the story. Inside, the intelligent Parasite lures Kal-El down into the basement. Lulled by the Doc's frozen arm, Superman flies full speed at him - only to be robbed of his momentum by the Parasite. Freeman/Jones grabs him and begins draining him of his energy. Freeman tries to elicit some sympathy about the importance of his own life over Superman's as he drains him. Michelinie leaves us with a cliffhanger, to be continued. This story sets up Superman's powerless condition for the "Trial", shows the renamed Team Luthor as the Centurions and was an interesting take on the Parasite. The "Trial" moves closer and while this story was a lead into it, there were none of the more overt signs as there have been in the other books. No bounty hunters, circling spaceships or a run through of Superman's history (which was well done) were in evidence. If anything, it seemed more linked to "Underworld Unleashed" with Luthor's role in freeing the Parasite. Behind a captivating Dwyer/Rodier cover with Superman gazing into the maw of the Parasite lay some great artwork. No Kieron inside this month, instead we are treated to some wonderful art by Gil Kane and Denis Rodier. I much preferred this combination to the Kane/Rubinstein art in Superman of late. The features and feel all seemed to work better for me here. Details like the Marx Brothers (and I am biased, I'm a fan) were great. Superman's features were well-realized, particularly in the basement scenes at S.T.A.R. Labs. There was a dynamic flow to the art in shots like Clark flying back into his apartment. He was holding his cape, and the scene conveyed all the nuances of how natural he found it - and it looked like a small window. Kudos again to Glenn Whitmore for his colorings. The shadowed Kadabra talking to Luthor (it looks like Kadabra) and the Parasite himself all had depth. William J Nixon ================================================= 43. SUPERMAN: THE MAN OF STEEL #50, "Split Personality" Writer: Louise Simonson Penciller: Jon Bogdanove Inker: Dennis Janke $2.95 US/$4.25 CAN/#2.00 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.6/5.0 Shields AL: 4.0 Shields AW: 3.5 Shields - Intriguing beginning to the Trial Of Superman saga. Good writing and artwork. DS: 3.5 Shields - A pretty good issue. Cleaning up after Parasite seems to be more interesting than the beginning of the trial. Maybe it will make more sense when we get deeper into the Trial of Superman. JS: 3.5 Shields - A promising start to "The Trial of Superman!" The story was well told, and Bogdanove and Janke managed to impress me with their art for a change. The Earth is ringed by starships as the Trial of Superman begins in this #50 anniversary issue of SUPERMAN: THE MAN OF STEEL. But back on Earth, a mummified-appearing Superman has an even greater problem. Held firmly in the grasp of a "super-powered" Parasite, our hero is fading fast as the Special Crimes Unit attempts to subdue the Parasite and rescue Superman. But they fail at the first task, and the rescue of Superman costs them dearly. Just when it appears that everyone will become a meal for the Parasite, Alpha Centurion appears on the scene with a revitalized Team Luthor -- now called the Centurions. Alpha Centurion goes one on one with the Parasite as the rest of the team attempts to extricate Superman and the SCU. Just when it appears they will make it out, agents of the Tribunal arrive and arrest Kal-El. The agents recognize him by his uniform, but are confused by Superman's feeble state. Using the "logic" of Sins of the Fathers, Kal-El is charged with the destruction of Krypton. As this is occurring, Alpha Centurion claims to know the newly-arrived beings, and orders the Centurions to get the SCU out of here, because "...they are no threat to US!" With Superman firmly in grasp, the agents beam back aboard the starship as quickly as they arrived. The battle between Alpha Centurion and the Parasite cools down and heats up as each tricks and is tricked by the other's cleverness. Sorry for the lack of detail, but as you have probably guessed from my other reviews, I really dislike this Alpha Centurion guy, and it is growing stronger all the time! But, back in the Spaceship the real story is developed. As the ship prepares to sling-shot around the sun, the members of the crew are debating whether Kal-El's powers have been removed or highly exaggerated. The brute who captured Superman leads him to a cell and contemplates the events which have brought them together. Sulking that he did not get the opportunity to fight Superman, he recalls how his Milk Brother and he are being manipulated by the Tribunal. The Brute fears that his Milk Brother, Mope, will be killed by the Tribunal, even though the Brute has done his duty in capturing the Man of Steel. Outraged, he seeks vengeance for himself and Mope on Superman. Superman is aware of the Brute's earlier anger and has planed to try to trick him and escape. Feeding the flames of the Brute's anger, Superman tricks him. But, the plan is not perfect as in his weakened condition he is slowed, and he is knocked out of the ship and deep into outer space. Bleeding internally and losing consciousness Superman, fears he is going to die. But in the absence of the filtration of the Sun's rays by the atmosphere, Superman is rapidly restored to full power and MORE! Back on Earth, the battle between the Parasite and Alpha Centurion continues. "Jim" Olsen and his video crew run off to get more stunning visual footage, but Lois Lane instinctively stays and gets the human interest story about how the Parasite has absorbed Dr. Freeman's intellect as well as his vital force. Alpha Centurion attempts to subdue the Parasite by reasoning with him through Freeman's family. During the negotiation the corpse of Freeman is regurgitated by the Parasite and he is able to escape. Later, we find that the loss of the corpse was subterfuge and that Freeman's intellect remains within the Parasite. Back in space, the Brute gets his chance to battle a "super" Superman. But, the Brute is unable to contend with Superman and his ever increasing power levels from the unfiltered sunlight. The fight quickly ends as the Brute is hurled toward the Sun. Superman quickly flies to the Brute's aid, and they are both captured by the starship's towbeam and are whisked away. In an effort to contain his powers, Superman allows himself to be captured by the paralysis rays that the Brute can generate. As this is occurring, other agents of the Tribunal arrive and place both the combatants in stasis chains. Superman and the Brute are brought before the Tribunal, and we begin to see the true horror of the Tribunal as "justice" is quickly dealt. The Brute is condemned to death for losing his temper and causing the near loss of Superman, and he is rocketed towards the sun where he appears to begin to melt. Superman is outraged, but instead of discussion, the Tribunal charges him with one billion counts of murder... This issue raised a lot of strong feelings in me. The Parasite-drained Superman was painful to look at. He was nearly sucked dry. He looked horrible, but the effect works. The Parasite sucks the life right out of you, and that is what appears to have happened. The next aspect of the book which raised my blood pressure was Alpha Centurion. I do not like him. His "Oh, well" attitude as Superman is taken into custody really bugged me. But since it bugged me, I think it is there for a purpose. This guy has a darker side, and I think it will be exploited in the near future. (Spoiler: read backwards "eb lliw ti !sey hO" -- dias ehs dna nosnomiS htiw gnikaeps saw I ) There was a lot of fighting in this issue. It gives Bog a lot of chances to strut his stuff. His flair for the dynamic is one of the best. There are a lot of good panels here. I liked them a lot. Not only were there a lot of fights, but The Trial of the Century starts here -- move over O.J!! 8 ) But at the rapidity that the Brute was judged, I do not think the time in court will last long for Kal-El. There is a double meaning for trial -- I loved it. The other great thing about this book is that Superman is powered back up. I am glad. From the publicity blurbs, I was worried that he would have to go through this story as a shadow of himself. I would like to make a public wish, here. I wish that The Brute turns out okay. I felt deeply for him and his love for his Milk Brother. The "damage" caused by the sun, where he looks like he is melting, could also be explained by tears and ah, well, drool. He did not seem too phased when Superman hurled him too close to the Sun. I hope we get to see a family reunion. If not at the end of the trial, then somewhere in a future issue. How about it, please? Arthur LaMarche ================================================= 44. SUPERMAN #106, "Condemned!" Writer: Dan Jurgens Penciller: Ron Frenz Embellisher: Joe Rubinstein Cover: Dan Jurgens & Joe Rubinstein $1.95 US/$2.75 CAN/#1.25 UK RATINGS: Average: 4.0/5.0 Shields KM: 5.0 Shields AL: 4.0 Shields AW: 3.5 Shields - Decent story--glad to finally be rid of Massacre. Ron Frenz is a welcome addition to the Superman team. DS: 3.5 Shields - It becomes clearer. Tribunal justice sez Superman must be held responsible for the sins of his ancestors -- the BANE of DC continuity. JS: 4.0 Shields - A very impressive debut by Ron Frenz, and a chilling look at the concepts of justice. (Not that I'm gonna miss Massacre...) Superman, tightly bound in chains and cuffs, pleads NOT GUILTY to the crime of blowing up Krypton and the murder of its one billion inhabitants. However, the Tribunal appears to have already found him guilty without the benefit of a real trial. Helpless, Superman tries to think back through the eons of Kryptonian history to see why he should be responsible for something that he had no control over. He realizes there is no reasoning with the Tribunal Prime. He breaks free of his chains and realizes his super powers have been erased. A genetilock is placed on him and he is shot through the transtube to a holding cell. There he confronts another nightmare--Massacre! And you think YOU'VE had a bad day!! Though similarly de-powered, Massacre lays claim to Superman and threatens to kill him long before the Tribunal can. Meanwhile, Superman thinks about what a great day today has been. The two mix it up for a while, but eventually the guards show up and put a halt to the brawl. The guards are not planing something as benevolent as breaking up the fight, instead, they have come for Massacre. Massacre is brought before the judges and found guilty of his heinous crimes against the cosmos. The sentence is a vicious beating by survivors of Massacre's homicidal offenses. Superman is outraged over this perverted miscarriage of justice and realizes he cannot escape without help. Back on Earth, Jim Olsen conducts a televised interview with Alpha Centurion (*Grrr* -- Art) Alpha Centurion nearly breaks his arm patting himself on the back and refers to Jimmy as "boy". After the interview, the arrogance continues. Alpha Centurion tells the team to "... Call again should the need arise." and then he tries to flatter Lois with really cheesy lines. Not knowing where else to turn in her attempt to locate her fiancee', Lois has to play Alpha Centurion's game and follows him to his ship. It is there we get another view of what has bothered me since Alpha Centurion's arrival -- his ship larger then Superman's monument, clearly stationed above it. Alpha Centurion is obviously making up for an inferiority complex, in my opinion. With his hand firmly upon Lois's shoulder, the flirting continues and the search is begun. The computers are unable to help locate Superman, but we the readers are better able to see that Alpha Centurion is BAD NEWS! Art: This issue was beautifully drawn, and the expressions and body gestures are well done. There is also great use of color. The colors seem to leap right off the page. The stuff is beautiful. There are also more subtle things, like the red used in the execution of Massacre, that add a lot to the book. The Trial of Superman (and for Lois for that matter) really starts to shift into high gear in this issue. We clearly see that this trial will not last long and Superman will be condemned. Even Cochran and Clark working together could not sway the Tribunal rock-heads. There is a brief fight for the action conscious, but this issue has much more psychological action. We see the darker side of Alpha Centurion really spreading out. Now Lois has to deal with him -- his hand is on her shoulder, but clearly removed in the next panel. But most importantly we see a very closed-minded Tribunal. Their way is the correct way and it is not open for discussion. Ken: This story has some real possibilities. I especially appreciate all the history that is being told about Krypton, the clone war, and the Eradicator. Ken McKee Arthur LaMarche ================================================= 45. ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN #529, "Jail Break!" Writer: Karl Kesel Penciller: Stuart Immonen Inker: Jose Marzan, Jr. $1.95 US/$2.75 CAN/#1.25 UK RATINGS: Average: 4.0/5.0 Shields AW: 4.0 Shields - Finely-balanced combination of action and characterization, with great artwork and exemplary coloring to boot! AL: 4.0 Shields - still good stuff! DS: 3.5 Shields - This story (so far) seems to be more interesting than I feared. At this stage it's better than DoCK and light years ahead of Dead Again. JS: 4.5 Shields - Exquisite art (especially lovely renditions of Supergirl & Steel), and wonderful characterizations by Mr. Kesel. So far, I'm *very* pleased with "The Trial of Superman!" It's a terrible thing to contemplate, but a few more issues like this, and I may have to turn in my "grouchy critic" badge. [*crash* Art just fell out of his chair. Hmm.. who can I find to replenish that role? 8 P ] Try as I might, I can only think of nice things to say about AOS #529 This story has several layers to it; there's the ongoing trials of Superman and his "pod mates," Leeya, Smitty, and Mope, and their escape from the Tribunal; there's the Alpha Centurion, gathering the Superman Rescue Squad to attempt Superman's rescue; there's Jimmy Olsen and Cat Grant, earning the professional respect of their peers; and there's Lois Lane, holding her own professionally and emotionally in the wake of her fiancee's disappearance. Kesel manages to balance these layers effectively, giving us enough action to keep the story moving along, while at the same time spending enough time with each character to let us know something more about each of them. I find the mix of pod mates interesting; two powerful, savage beings, one small, cowardly being, and one of the galaxy's greatest heroes, all "guilty" of varying degree of crimes, and all chained together. What do I mean by "varying degrees of crime"? Well, the only being I would consider truly evil would have to be Smitty. His race's campaign of galactic genocide is clearly reprehensible. But by following the ages-old tradition of patricide, Leeya is simply guilty of carrying out the traditions of her people. Do we think it's wrong? Certainly, especially in the light of the existence of "synthetic substitutes." But would this tradition be more effectively deterred by punishment or by cultural education and enlightenment? While Superman's case clearly shows the Tribunal's methods to be wrong and narrow-sighted, Leeya's case, in a less obvious fashion, shows the error of the Tribunals "extreme punishment" version of law enforcement. I have to admit, I'm still a little confused about Mope. Just what was he doing with a "missing" shipment of potion? Is he guilty merely of ignorance, or is there more to this than we think? The Alpha Centurion's motives are a little more obvious; he clearly has something unpleasant planned for Superman, and probably the rest of the Superman Rescue Squad. What is he up to exactly? I don't know, but he knows a little too much about the Tribunal not to be involved (though his remark, "Fate forces my hand too soon," puzzles me). I think I know his true identity (and no, I'm not going to spoil it for anyone else), but I can't figure out what he wants with the rest of Superman's closest allies. [I think I know, also, and I know what "he" would want with the rest of the team -- I wonder if we are thinking about the same person -- Art] Finally, nods to the treatment of the Superman supporting cast. I like Cat's new assertiveness and Jimmy growing into a dynamic, respected reporter in his own right. Now, if they just keep their eyes on that villainous Morgan Edge hanging out in the background... Oh--and I'd be remiss if I don't mention the subtle touches of humor and nostalgia Kesel added to the mix. For example, Jimmy's remark that "I'd believe Superman had a big, red ant head before I'd believe he was a coward" recalls one of the more bizarre red Kryptonite stories of the '60's. And I don't know about you, but Superboy's crack to Alpha Centurion, "Hey- you need a spit-curl to get on this ship," cracked me up. Immonen and Marzan do their usual excellent job on the artwork. I'd also like to say how much Glenn Whitmore adds to the issue. His subtle coloring gives the art an almost three-dimensional texture that does credit to the new printing process. This is one of the few comics where I think that the extra price is really worth it. I didn't have a lot of hope for the original premise of the "Trial of Superman" storyline, but issues like this have made me begin to eagerly anticipate the next chapter in the saga. Anatole ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 3 _________________________________________________________________ OTHER SUPER-TITLES: ------------------ SUPERBOY #21, "Making History!" (Future Tense: Part 1 of 3) Writer: Karl Kesel Artist: Tom Grummett Inker: Doug Hazlewood Cover: Tom Grummett & Karl Kesel $1.95 US/$2.75 CAN/#1.25 UK RATINGS: Average: 4.0/5.0 Shields VC: 4.0 Shields AL: 3.5 Shields AW: 4.5 Shields - Superboy fits well into the new Legion. Well done! DS: 4.0 Shields - In this story the Legion looks interesting enough for me to follow the rest of this story line to conclusion. JS: 4.0 Shields - A rip-roaring fun story, yet again courtesy of Karl Kesel. Must admit, though, that Grummett's Legion looks a bit older than teenagers. As Superboy is sweating out a history exam, a group of denizens from the 30th century materialize somewhere in Hawaii. Brainiac 5, Cosmic Boy, Triad, Chameleon, and Saturn Girl arrive, freezing from effects of time travel. XS is the only teammate not to have appeared, and although Cos is determined to retrieve her before continuing their mission, he's persuaded by Brainiac 5, who assures him that with time travel technology, he'll be able to rescue her at any moment in history. Subsequently, Saturn Girl telepathically scans for Superboy and locates him at the compound, where he is lamenting over his implanted knowledge, or rather the lack of it. As he is discussing his academic problems with Roxy, the Legionnaires are below ground, beneath the compound, after tracking Superboy to it. Chameleon changes into a Buzekian stone-borer, a green behemoth who tunnels upwards and breaks through the floor of the complex. Fearing an attack, Superboy quickly flies upward with Chameleon while the rest of the Legionnaires exit the underground cavern and follow suit. In the air, the Legionnaires attempt to restrain him as Roxy, in a futile attempt, tries to stop Saturn Girl from mentally subduing him. Dubbilex rushes out from the (mental) commotion and at Superboy's request, telepathically links everyone except Roxy to each other. When told of the mission, Superboy takes the Legionnaires to S.T.A.R. Labs. There, he explains how he saved Valor by sending him into a stasis zone. Saturn Girl deduces that Superboy may still have subconscious memory of that event that she could transfer to Brainiac 5 in order to construct a similar device. She enacts the memory transfer and before Brainiac 5 can even begin any work, he is severely annoyed at the primitive technology at his disposal. Frustrated, and without warning, Brainiac 5 sends his team and Superboy back to the 30th century! In the meantime, Knockout has decided to leave the dancing club and move into the compound -- much to the shock of everyone there! Wow, what a long build-up to this storyline. I think it was worth it just to see SB give Brainiac 5 a few funny comments. Kesel carries his (Brainiac's) arrogance into the 20th century perfectly. As a matter of fact, I think that this collaboration will probably be one of the better crossovers in the DC universe this year for the simple fact that the writers on SB, Legionnaires and LSH are all great writers. I admit there weren't very many surprises in the plot but I think the subsequent parts to the story-arc holds much promise. Personally, I wonder if the LSH know that Superboy isn't really a young Clark Kent - that could hold a lot of fun in store. Anyhow, Kesel, has done a good job of transporting the team over from the 30th century, their personalities intact, and strangely enough, it doesn't faze Superboy, who's grown up with implanted knowledge and MTV. In the meantime, it seems that Kesel, Mark Waid, Tom McCraw and Tom Peyer are planning on revitalizing the 30th Century *their* way. Events that seem to bear resemblance to the Silver Age Superboy and the LSH seem to me to be amusing. Live Wire lost his arm, and now the LSH is trying to save Valor. In a way, it's like history (or is that the future) is repeating itself. Similar events, just different contexts. The writing was still solid even for a somewhat predictable plot. The dialogue made up for that aspect I think. In addition, I am glad to see Tom and Doug back at the drawing boards! I don't think the readership could take it if they had to leave this series. Overall, this first of three parts had a simple premise and story, but the character interaction and the art helped beef it up. I'm looking forward to the next two parts (in LSH #74 and LEGIONNAIRES #31) when the Kid will get his first glimpse into the future. Victor Chan ================================================= STEEL #21, "Stalker" Writer: Louise Simonson Penciller: Phil Gosier Inker: Rich Faber $1.95 US/$2.75 CAN/#1.25 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.75/5.0 Shields DS: 4.0 Shields - One of the best issues of Steel in ages. JS: 3.5 Shields - One of the better Steel stories I've read. Steel and Metallo seem like a natural match-up. Tie ins: Underworld Unleashed, Trial of Superman Well the first team is back this month for one of the best issues of Steel in recent memory, in fact one of the best ever. Steel is helping capture looters during a riot, when a couple of massive explosions occur. After saving the victims of the explosions, Steel is confronted by Metallo -- a new and improved version who was given special powers by Neron. Steel makes quick work of Metallo, hitting him in the head with his hammer and completely severing it from his body. Unfortunately, this fight occurs in a junk yard and Metallo's head morphs a bunch of old auto parts into a new body! He shoots Steel with the gasoline still in the tank of the morphed car and pummels him with his fists, now made out of car engines. Steel escapes and manages to knock Metallo's head off again and this time he knocks it into the Potomac river. Steel returns to the scene of the second explosion and rescues more victims. He briefly talks to Lt. Beryl about his fight with Metallo. Meanwhile, Metallo's head has managed to find a bunch of stuff that has been dumped in the bottom of the river over the past hundred years and constructs a new body. He then commandeers a police boat, attaches the boat's gun to his arm, and goes off in search of Steel. Upon finding Steel, he prepares to kill him but decides to grant Steel a last request. Metallo explains his new-found power. Neron gave a bunch of DC Universe villains candles. If the candles were burned at both ends at midnight on one particular day, the villains were transported to a demon realm. Each villain was offered a power of his (or her) choosing in return for the promise to serve Neron. Metallo chose the power to never again have his head separated from his body -- which means that he can create a new body from any metal that his head finds. So, Metallo takes the next logical step -- he decides Steel's armor would make an ideal addition to his body. But it doesn't work. Steel slugs Metallo again and breaks his head off. He gives the head to Shauna Beryl with instructions to take the head to S.T.A.R. labs and to keep it away from metal on the way. Meanwhile, another bomb is located in the sub-basement of Washington General Hospital. The bomb has a metal casing and is tamper proof. Steel grabs the bomb and flies away with it. Naturally Metallo escapes by taking Shauna's revolver and then quickly gets a new body and comes after Steel. How can Steel save the city and defeat Metallo? Is there any hope for our hero? Well, let's see. The bomb casing is made of metal so Metallo takes the bomb from Steel to make it part of his body since he can now control metal objects. Our hero is doomed. Well, almost. Unfortunately the explosive mechanism in the bomb being controlled by Metallo is not metal, it is plastique. BOOM!!!! No more Metallo. The shock wave from the explosion knocks Steel out. As he plummets to earth, he is grabbed by the Alpha Centurion, who recruits him to join his trip to save Superman. I like to include a few examples of dialogue, but I couldn't remember any that cried out to be included. So I reread the entire issue specifically looking for something humorous or unusual or foreshadowing. I found none. This issue was mostly a fight issue exhibiting courage, heroism and intelligence, particularly on the part of Metallo. As such there was no subtle characterization that Simonson is known for. Phil Gosier continues his style of very sharp images with numerous splash pages, most of which are overlaid with story panels. Rich Faber's inks match this style very well. There is very little background to most of the panels. The colors are crisp. The expression on his face when Metallo discovers the bomb is plastique is almost worth the price of admission. (For those of you who do not read Steel, it's on page 20, if you want a quick look.) If you are not turned off by stories that are mostly fights, you should read this issue. If you don't like it, then Steel is definitely not for you. Dick Sidbury (sidbury@cs.uofs.edu) ================================================= SHOWCASE '95 #10, "Rock Bottom" Starring Gangbuster Story: Jerry Ordway Art: Joe Staton & Horacio Ottolini Cover: Ron Frenz & Dennis Janke $2.95 US/$4.25 CAN/#2.00 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.9/5.0 Shields RG: Story: 4.0 Shields - Strong stand-alone story, good characterization. Art: 3.5 Shields - Nicely drawn and inked, but too dark. JS: 4.0 Shields - Wonderful story by Jerry Ordway, but the art was a bit dark for my tastes. Jose Delgado (Gangbuster) is still on the run from the law in Metropolis, where he has been charged with assault by some gangsters that he put in the hospital (see the "World Without a Superman" and ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN #500 for details). He has been drifting from city to city, unable to get or keep a job. This story picks up from where he left Brick City (see BLACK LIGHTNING). Jose is escorting 12 year old runaway Daphne back to her family in Fawcett City. After he delivers her to her parents, he goes down to the dock looking for work. He doesn't find any, but he does get involved with a local bare knuckle fight promoter. After doing one fight for the guy, he decides to take his winnings and leave town, but the promoter has other ideas. After framing Jose for murder (that never happened), the promoter tells Jose that he can get the charges dropped if he does one more fight. Jose reluctantly agrees, fights, and wins, only to find out that it is supposed to be a fight to the death. The crowd is out for Jose's blood when the police raid the place, arresting everyone. Jose thinks he's finally had it, only to find out that he has actually been rescued by Daphne and her (Chief of Police) father. This was an excellent, stand alone story that anyone could read and enjoy. It deals closely with the personality of Gangbuster, a very under-used member of the Superman supporting cast. This is the type of story I was hoping to get in this book when I found out that Showcase was going to deal with the cast of Superman this year. It was truly one of the best stand-alone stories I've read in the title. My only complaint was that while the art was nicely detailed and inked, the overall darkness of the scenes made it look muddy. I know that it was supposed to add to the overall feel of the story, but many of the details were nearly lost. "Benefactors," starring Darkstar Ferrin Colos Writer: Michael T. Collins Penciller: Jesse D. Orozco Inker: David A. Roach Colos shows a conquered people that the Anzodorl (the aliens who had rescued them), who were being worshipped like gods and ritually feeding off them, could be defeated. This means that the people could revolt and eventually take back their world. A nice story. Read like one of the old Adam Strange stories of the seventies, but didn't involve any member of the Superman cast. "Be Careful what you Wish for," starring Hi-Tech (Part 1 of 2) Writer: Barry Kitson Penciller: Lee Sullivan Inker: Ray McCarthy RG: Story: 3.5 shields - Nicely narrated part one, would rate higher if it was a stand alone. Art: 4.0 shields - Clean, well-detailed art, nicely inked. JS: 4.0 Shields - An interesting "near-Elseworlds" tale by Kitson, and nice art by Sullivan. Hi-Tech dreams of a second chance in a fairy world where magic rules and she is good and kind. She is in love with Superman, and in her dreams he comes to love her. At least until the Troll King and his Dark Legions come and capture them. Superman's mind is taken over, and Hi-Tech gives her soul to the Troll King to release him. She then wakes to discover that she was under the control of Killgrave the entire time. The story concludes next issue. A nice quiet imaginary story that is used as a lead-in to next month's. I enjoy seeing some of Superman's more reluctant foes being given a chance to show their true colors in these stories. I would have enjoyed it more if it hadn't been continued, but we don t always get everything that we want. The art in the story was clean and well detailed, making the fairy tale atmosphere much more enjoyable. The inking added shading and depth. Rene' Gobeyn ================================================= SHOWCASE '95 #11, "The End" Starring Agent Liberty Writer: Dan Jurgens Layouts: Joe St. Pierre Finishes: Rod Ramos Cover: Dan Jurgens & Mike Sellers $2.95 US/$4.25 CAN/#2.00 UK RATINGS: Average: 2.4/5.0 Shields RG: Story: 4.0 Shields - Strong, well-written and complete, nicely done. Art: 1.5 Shields - Dark and over inked, perspective and proportions wrong. JS: 2.0 Shields - While this was an interesting idea, the execution fell flat. This one starts off with Ben Lockwood (Agent Liberty) trying to find out who the Sons Of Liberty are that are trying to blow up the government buildings in Washington DC. The police are against him, as he was known to be a member of the Sons when the original group tried to take over the government by subversion and assassination. He manages to stop one of the bombings and save the life of the bomber, only to find out that the new group practically worships him. He manages to trick the bomber into taking him back to the headquarters of the group. The New Sons are a bunch of weekend warrior types, overweight and under-trained. Ben finds out that the leader of this group is actually the leader of the original Sons, an old friend named Paul Devlin, who Ben thought had died. Naturally Ben and Paul fight. The New Sons decide to help their boss, but since they are so badly trained, they end up shooting him instead of Agent Liberty. Paul truly dies in Ben's arms this time, and Ben disarms and routs the Sons. He is so disgusted that the group had misunderstood his aims and ambitions that he burns his costume, totally destroying what had given him his powers and abilities. Agent Liberty is dead, giving birth to a now whole and healthy Benjamin Lockwood. I hope we haven t seen the last of him. "Escape," starring Arkham Asylum Writer: Archie Goodwin Art: Gene Ha An escape from Arkham Asylum. It's not quite what you expect. A decent story with slightly above average art. A good read, but it has nothing to do with Superman or his cast. "The Price," starring Hi-Tech (Part 2 of 2) Story: Barry Kitson Pencils: Lee Sullivan Inks: Ray McCarthy RG: Story: 4.0 Shields - Tight story, good intro. to Hi-Tech and Killgrave. Art: 4.0 Shields - Nicely detailed and inked, excellent layouts. JS: 3.0 Shields - The art wasn't as good as the first part. Though this degenerated into a slugfest, I am somewhat curious as to what will happen next. The story picks up from where it left off last issue. Hi-Tech has just discovered that Killgrave rescued her from where she was being held at S.T.A.R. Labs. He built her a new body, and now expects her to use her power to completely control machinery to help him in his project to kill Superman. After seeing how she truly feels about Superman last issue, it is understandable when she lashes out at Killgrave and refuses to help him. At this point, Superman crashes in and tries to capture them. There is a brief (thankfully) fight and Hi-Tech discovers that it is really a robot and not Superman. She tries to destroy Killgrave and escape, only to discover that the body Killgrave gave her is not organic, but robotic, and he added a feature that allows him to shut her body down anytime he wants to. All-in-all a well done little story. I m glad that it was done here instead of in the mainline Superman titles. This will probably turn into a lead-in to a new Superman plot involving Killgrave and Hi-Tech. I do hope it's short. Killgrave has never been a favorite of mine, but Hi-Tech as an ally could show some promise. Rene' Gobeyn ================================================= THE NEW TITANS #127, "A Desperate Search" (Meltdown #3) Writer: Marv Wolfman Penciller: William Rosado Inkers: Will Blyberg & Fred Fredericks $2.25 US/$3.25 CAN/#1.50 UK RATINGS: Average: 4.0/5.0 Shields RG: Story: 4.5 Shields - Starts to wrap things up, Damage leaves. Art: 4.5 Shields - Well done, fine details, excellent backgrounds. JS: 3.5 Shields - Since I'm only buying this title for Supergirl, I was disappointed that she didn't appear even once. Nonetheless, Wolfman's started a pretty good story here. Since Supergirl doesn't even appear in this book, I'll keep this short. The Tamaran in the Vegan system is under attack by Gordanians. Queen Komand'r and an injured Koriand'r are trying to reach Earth to get help. Meanwhile, Mirage is ill and is being teleported to S.T.A.R. Labs Hospital for treatment. Damage quits the team and leaves because of Arsenal's attitudes. Meanwhile, the Technus have rescued Komand'r and Koriand'r and come under attack by the Gordanians. The Technus entity Cyberion and the Tamaranians win the brief fight and discover that the Gordanians are on the way to Earth. Meanwhile, the Titans arrive at S.T.A.R. Labs to discover that Changeling has escaped and is tearing the place up to find them. The Titans have fought and defeated him when Cyberion, Komand'r and Koriand'r arrive. Technus puts a shield around him to protect Changeling. This is when we discover that Cyberion is really Cyborg, one of the original New Titans. Well, most of the gang is now together again. We have Changeling, Cyborg, Wonder Girl (Donna Troy - Darkstar), and Starfire (Koriand'r). We all know that Raven and Nightwing and the original New Titans will all be together again. I am not sure how Marv is planning to bring in the others, but somehow I'm sure he will. With only three more issues to the end of the title, he had better hurry. A truly fun read, some good bits of characterization and plenty of history for new readers. The art in the book is spectacular, lots of detail, good use of perspective and shadows for depth. This title is going to go out with a bang! Rene' Gobeyn ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 4 ________________________________________________________________ ANNUALS, SPECIALS, AND CROSSOVERS: --------------------------------- ACTION COMICS ANNUAL #7, "Loss and Space!" Writer: David Michelinie Penciller: Darick Robertson Inker: Brad Vancata With a tip of the concept cap to Brett Breeding Cover by Walt Simonson $3.95 US/$5.50 CAN/#2.50 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.75/5.0 Shields WN: 3.5 Shields - Some great space art, but Superman seemed almost arrogant about his powers. AW: 3.5 Shields - Young Superman's and pacifist society's attitudes were intriguing and well-written. DS: 3.5 Shields - My vote for the best Superman annual this year. JS: 4.5 Shields - Best Superman story Michelinie's written. Period. Very nicely illustrated, as well. The final "Year One" annual for Superman this year, and the spotlight is turned on space -- Superman's first trip beyond Earth and some realizations about his limitations. To some extent, I thought this annual should have been entitled "I'm Superman" - there was a self-sure (almost) arrogance about this young Man of Steel. Where was the unsure figure who saved the Constitution? The characterization was critical, though, in exploring the lessons which Clark learned about himself. He is a young man suddenly liberated by his costume and the knowledge that bullets bounce off him. He feels the rush that being Superman brings, who wouldn't be a little overwhelmed? So, to the story. Superman hears a distress signal from the moon. Clark has never left Earth and flies to the moon to find a dying alien. The alien asks for his help in defending their planet from the genocidal H'tros. A spacecraft carries Kal-El to their world and he defeats these marauders. He learns fear as he runs out of oxygen and panic as he tries to remember how to get home. Suddenly he knows he could die. He returns to Earth. The H'tros turn their attention to Earth, and while Clark has some momentary frissons of fear he knows what he must do. He goes to fight them. He discovers their leader, who created these "peacemakers" during the fray. Without the H'tros to sustain him, the leader commits suicide. Back on Earth he receives a victory parade. Superman realizes he still has a lot to learn and talks it over with Pa. Pa tells him that they raised a good boy who has become a good man. Clark was taught to do what was right for the deed -- not the consequences. I liked this annual. It was part space opera, part down-home homily and it worked for me. I loved the art -- Robertson and Vancata did some great set pieces: the destroyed mother ship inside the S-Shield, Superman escaping Earth's gravity and the brilliant two-page change of outfit scene. Clark in a double-breasted suit in a wonderful '40's homage, transforming into the Man of Steel. Great. Their space shots, with colorist Pat Garrahy gave new depth to Earth. Annuals seem to be moving into the graphic novel look, and it was interesting comparing the look of this one to S:MoS's this year which was released in the non-glossy paper. I liked the look of Action. Lots of little details were cool, too. An entire wardrobe of outfits at the Kents farm, Martha must have been busy. This was Superman's first trip into space, and it's a trip I enjoyed. William J Nixon ================================================= SUPERBOY ANNUAL #2, "The Lost Boys" Writers: Karl & Barbara Kesel Penciller: David Brewer Inkers: Andre parks, Pam Eklund, Ken Branch, & Wayne Faucher Cover: David Brewer & Karl Kesel $3.95 US/$5.50 CAN/#2.50 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.5/5.0 Shields MC: 4.0 Shields - Great story, but Brewer's art didn't interest me at all. AW: 3.0 Shields - Average action, but good segments with Bizarro SB and Superman at the end. JS: 3.5 Shields - While David Brewer's art did absolutely nothing for me, Karl Kesel's story is a fun ride. Superboy does his good deed for the day as we start the story, attending a birthday party for a handicapped child. Superboy (by my own preference called SB herewithin) takes him for a few laps around the clouds to perk up the boy's special day. He even goes so far as to show him how to "pick up babes," as he swoops down and picks up Tana Moon, who just happens to be covering a broadcast *live* at the time. The boy's mother thanks SB and tells him his parents must be proud of him, and SB isn't reluctant to tell her of his true heritage as a clone. Afterwards, SB returns to his beachfront home in Honolulu, to find Dubbilex groaning from the pain of a mental contact with Guardian at Project Cadmus. Dubbilex tells SB that there's "urgent business" waiting for them at Project Cadmus. Next we see, SB, Dubbilex, and Guardian travel through the aftermath of what was once Project Cadmus, 'til they meet up with Gilotina, a girl from the slave-ridden world of Apokolips. She guards the entrance to the "secret chamber" that holds the "urgent business" SB and Dubbilex were sent to investigate. Soon the directors of Project Cadmus arrive, all waiting to see what waits for them behind the doors. As Guardian opens the door, SB, Dubbilex, and the rest of the gang are astonished as they gaze upon (Surprise!) a room full of Superboys (Like we didn't know that from the front cover)!!! Ones with big heads, skinny ones, tall ones, and one that looks *very* similar to our resident S-Shield wearer. As Doctor Packard proceeds to explain his involvement with these clones, we find out that these clones are the first twelve unsuccessful tries of cloning Superman , until they happened upon our SB, the thirteenth try. While explaining, a loud noise emanates from the air shaft, meaning only one thing: The Newsboy Legion! (Who else?) And knowing how careless the Newsboys can sometimes be, Scrapper accidentally leans up against the control panel of the pod that holds the very similar SB clone. Everything seems to be all right once checked out by Doc Packard, that is, until later, when, from another room, they hear a loud crash and find one of the SB clones missing; the first one to be exact. And so the hunt begins...... Turns out the first clone was made using the same technique Lex Luthor (Ol' baldy himself) used in creating the Bizarro Superman. So now we face the new and improved Bizarro Superboy!!( Y'know, I always felt sorry for those guys.....) After the BS makes a fatal mistake of chasing after Gilotina, she absent-mindedly uses her powers, which crack the faulty ground that Guardian, the Newsboy Legion, and Charlie are on. (Oh, didn't I mention Charlie? Yeah, big pink monster. Pretty much sums him up.) In the meantime, Dubbilex gets his clock cleaned by the BS, prompting a fight between pale face and the real thing. As all Super-Bizarros seem to do, the BS sees the attack as a need to prove that he is the *real* SB. And all the while, SB is cracking jokes.......don't ya just love it? And being the (sometimes) clever guy he is, he devises a plan to both stop the fight and save Guardian, Gilotina, the Legion, and Charlie from the seemingly bottomless chasm. In the process of saving them, the BS gets the living daylights knocked out of him when he gets hit by a large chunk of the floor. Taken to the medical lab, Doc Packard acknowledges that this is, indeed, the same process that L.L. used to make the Bizarro Superman, and that there is no plausible way to save him. Things couldn't get worse. Couldn't, that is, until Director Gabrielli gives SB the news that he's wanted to know ever since he found out he wasn't cloned from Superman: Who exactly *is* he cloned from? And the winner is(drumroll, please)........... ...............................Paul Westfield! Yes, as in the long-dead, slimy, evil, filthy snake of a man, and the Executive Director of Cadmus on the side. And also SB's greatest fear: that Westfield is his "dad." In all the confusion and disbelief, the BS dies, but dies with a happy thought, believing that he was cloned from a "great man" with "great honor." And so goes life. And life goes on. And so does SB, as he returns to his home in Honolulu. And a surprise visitor pops in to greet him. None other than the most legendary of all super-heroes: Superman!!! Supes and SB have a man-to-man (man-to-boy?) talk about what has happened with SB finding out that he was actually cloned from Paul Westfield. Supes, being the cool guy that he is, helps SB to deal with his newfound heritage. SB, feeling confident now, decides to confront his homework that he skipped during this whole saga. Returning to the house, he finds that all his friends have gathered to celebrate his very first birthday! It's been exactly one year since he escaped Cadmus, and his friends weren't about to let something like that slide by. Oh, and we get to learn a moral in this story, kids! Friends stay beside their friends. (Can everybody say "Awwwww"?) I specifically enjoyed this whole story. I've wondered exactly who it was Superboy was cloned from ever since it was reported that it *wasn't* Superman. I'm not too thrilled with who it truly was, but it was intriguing nonetheless. I wasn't exactly put on by Brewer's artwork. To me, it looked like a bad try at copying Mike Wieringo's artwork. In any case, I still enjoyed it enough to give it 4 shields. Here's to SB and many adventures to come! Matt Combes (NandoM@aol.com) ================================================= SUPERMAN: AT EARTH'S END Writer: Tom Veitch Artist: Frank Gomez $4.95 US/$6.95 CAN RATINGS: Average: 1.5/5.0 Shields RG: Story: 2.5 Shields - Superman did not stay in character. Art: 4.5 Shields - Beautiful fully painted art worth the price. AL: 0.0 Shields - "Oh, I will use a gun to avenge my friend Bruce's death. He would want it that way, and while I am at it, why don't I kill everybody around and myself?" -- YEA, RIGHT!! GET REAL!! DS: 2.0 Shields - Elseworlds are supposed to be out of continuity. But Superman using a gun is hard to swallow and Superman deliberately killing individuals is impossible to believe. JS: 0.5 Shields - I'm ashamed that DC let this get published. You can't simply place Superman's shield on a big guy with guns and expect people to buy him as the Man of Steel. This was putrid. Before I get started, please remember that this is an ELSEWORLD(tm) book. Please do not confuse this book with anything remotely having to do with continuity. It is a strangely powerful story, but I had a little trouble with it because the Superman in the story was slightly out of character. [Slightly? For the Punisher, maybe... -- Jeff] He gives in way too easily, both about guns in general, and about killing. It could be that he is just tired, but it didn't seem that way to me. It wasn't much, but it was enough to spoil the latter part of the story for me. I think that if the main character had been anyone but Superman, I wouldn't have minded, but to have Superman go against his own principles for such a limited gain totally ruined my enjoyment. In many ways, the story reminds me of some of the old imaginary stories of the '60s. It was a lot of fun, but what really made the book was the artwork. The fully painted artwork made the images almost jump off the page. It is just about the best artwork I have seen in an ELSEWORLD book so far. This book picks up about a year after "Kamandi: At Earth's End" ended. Superman has been living with Ben Boxer and his Bio-mechs aboard Sky City, a huge flying city that floats above the polluted ruins of the Earth. Ben has just announced that he has scheduled Gotham City for destruction, and Superman disagrees. He leaves the city and is immediately attacked by bat-creatures who bear a strong resemblance to Bruce Wayne. The creatures take him off-guard, and he is rescued by a cycle gang of kids. The kids talk him into trying to rescue their parents and at the same time regain Bruce's remains from the DNA dictators. A battle ensues and Superman ends up employing "Big Guns" to win the battle. At the end, he decides that he can no longer live in what has become of his world and commits suicide. Rene' Gobeyn ================================================= LEGION OF SUPER-HEROES #74, "Prisoner of the Super-Heroes" (Future Tense: Part 2 of 3) Co-Plotters: Tom Peyer & Tom McCraw Scripter: Tom Peyer Penciller: Lee Moder Inker: Ron Boyd Cover: Alan Davis & Mark Farmer $2.25 US/$3.25 CAN/#1.50 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.75/5.0 Shields VC: 4.0 Shields AW: 3.5 Shields - Um, the Scavenger's 1000 years old? Weird. Superboy and the Legion together--verrry nice. DS: 3.5 Shields - I seldom buy crossover stories that move into other books. I'm glad I made this an exception. JS: 4.0 Shields - I don't particularly care for Moder's style, but his ability to draw facial expressions really contributes to a wonderful continuation of the tale. Hurtling through the timestream, the Legionnaires and Superboy find themselves in the 30th century. Almost immediately, Brainiac 5 starts work to free Valor and immediately displays an overbearing attitude towards Superboy. When Cosmic Boy instructs Triad and Chameleon to take Superboy on a tour, Triad's personality splits, literally, as one aspect of her (call her Triad3) decides to go with Superboy instead of waiting for Valor's recovery. Instantly, a feud starts among the three. Cosmic Boy, noticing the commotion surrounding Valor's return, declares the mission Top Secret. Cham and Triad3 take Superboy to the Monitor Room, where he mistakenly blabs about Valor's return while there is an open channel. The alien at the other end of the line immediately tries to profit by spreading the word. The trio, with Triad recombined, and Invisible Kid, Shrinking Violet and Leviathan, take a spacecraft to retrieve components for the Stasis Zone device from the planet Korr. Minutes later, Superboy encounters Ultra Boy, who informs him that he came to see what he could do to help in restoring Valor. At that point, Superboy knows how much of a faux pas he had made in the Monitor room. Reaching Korr, the team's advised that the item they need has been purloined. Hurrying to the location given to them, Superboy is face-to-face with Scavenger, who's convinced Superboy had been pursuing him among the centuries! A fight ensues, with Scavenger wielding the paraphernalia of several heroes of the 20th century. Superboy gains an upper hand by telekinetically disassembling the Blue Devil trident that Scavenger had been attacking with. Scavenger picks up an innocuous-looking rock that Superboy deems as non-menacing. He dares Scavenger to throw it. Instead, Scavenger reveals that he is holding the Philosopher's Stone and transmutes the air surrounding Superboy into Inertron! He quickly sends Cham into a crystal prison, transforms the air around Shrinking Violet to ammonia, Triad2 and Triad3 to birch and gold, and sends Triad1 and Leviathan into a pool of tar... Well, Superboy's penchant for little slips came up big-time in this issue. If the rest of the populace are half as fanatic as Triad about Valor's return, there could be some serious rioting going on. Superboy seems to adapt very well to his new environs, that is if there are pretty women nearby. That, of course, doesn't sit too well with some of the male Legionnaires, but he *is* Superboy. Brainiac points out also that Superboy is *not* a younger Superman. This issue was pretty fun. Superboy's first trip into the 30th century and he doesn't faze easily. Brainiac must have thought that bringing Valor out of the Stasis Zone may have been easy, but what was to have been a simple recovery mission for the Legionnaires and Superboy turned into a puzzling appearance of the Scavenger. The story had a nice twist with Scavenger's appearance and even more so when he bested the entire group by himself. Peyer and McCraw have kept Superboy true to his character and Lee Moder's pencils suit the comic and Superboy very nicely. Good job on this issue, guys! Victor Chan ================================================= LEGIONNAIRES #31, "One Thousand Years of Solitude" (Future Tense: Part 3 of 3) Plot: Tom Peyer & Tom McCraw Script: Tom Peyer Pencils: Jeffrey Moy Inks: W.C. Carani $2.25 US/$3.25 CAN/#1.50 UK RATINGS: Average: 3.75/5.0 Shields VC: 3.5 Shields AW: 3.5 Shields - Amazingly, the quality kept up through all three parts of this story. I really enjoyed it. DS: 3.5 Shields - A reasonable ending to a thoroughly enjoyable story. Maybe I'll pick up a few more issues of LSH books to see if they are uniformly this good. [A tip -- they are! -- Jeff] JS: 4.5 Shields - A fantastic finish to the crossover! And Jeff Moy (no bias because of his name, honest! :) is fast becoming one of my favorite artists. As Cosmic Boy supervises an energy discharge to allow Valor to be seen from the Stasis Zone, he reassures R.J. Brande and Madame President of Earth on the rescue of Valor from the Zone. Of course, Cosmic Boy doesn't realize the extent of the situation the other Legionnaires have found themselves in. Faced with imminent death, Scavenger gloats in front of them, transmuted elements barring any of their actions. That is until Chameleon transforms into a ferocious beast and shatters his crystal cage. As the Scavenger is beset by Cham, he loses grasp of the Philosopher's stone. Triad, sinking in a pool of tar, is able to hang on to it. Scavenger escapes from Cham's attack by grabbing the Atom's belt among the powerful equipment scattered around and shrinking out of sight. Fortunately, Violet had recovered from the ammonia attack and makes her move, striking Scavenger unconscious. With Superboy's help, Ultra Boy is able to use his Ultra-vision and recover the device needed to complete the Stasis Zone device. Upon their return to Earth, the rest of the away team realize that Superboy had let the cat of the bag, thus generating all the mass hysteria at Legion HQ. Cosmic Boy and Superboy entreat Brainiac 5 to find a solution, to render the Valor mission secret again. Superboy and Brainy take the device outside to the Main Plaza in front of many dignitaries and a huge throng awaiting Valor. Moments after they get the device working, it's disrupted and it shatters into pieces. Immediately, the Legion beat a hasty retreat while a mob ensues. Later in a desert in Qurac, Superboy and Brainiac are able to bring Valor out of the Stasis Zone in private and quickly apply the lead-poisoning serum to him. Upon arriving at Legion HQ, Triad immediately fawns over him, something that Valor finds very unsettling. Because of that kind of behavior, Cosmic Boy asks Valor to maintain a low profile. The statement angers him, and he blames the myths and devotion surrounding him to be the culprits of his unwanted popularity. As Superboy leaves, he gives a crying Triad a few encouraging words, resulting in a passioned response. Brainy accompanies Superboy to the Time Platform - he will be searching for XS once he's returned Superboy to the 20th century. Just before he leaves, Superboy is given two things from Cosmic Boy. One is a Legion flight ring and the other is an open invitation for membership with the LSH. Superboy returns to the past, leaving them in various states of emotions. As Future Tense concludes, I have to mention again that this has been one of the year's best multi-title story arcs, IMO. Although Jeff Moy's artwork is a little more 'cartoonish' than Grummett or Moder, it still lends itself to the young, fresh aspect of the Legion titles. The writing was quite good, and it shows that Peyer, McCraw and Kesel really got their ideas to mesh throughout the three issues of this series. I thought the idea to fake out the population on Valor's return was a genuinely great idea. Unfortunately, the Legion saw more of Superboy's clumsy side, but he did do his best to save Valor. It was his original deeds that convinced Cosmic Boy to bring him to the 30th century. Superboy comes across as a 20th century screw-up with good intentions, but I think that if he wasn't so girl-crazy, he'd make a fine Legionnaire. With this story arc, I'm hoping to see more of the Kid kicking 30th century butt! Victor Chan ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 5 _________________________________________________________________ LOOKING BACK ------------ Again we've no post-Crisis reviews this month, but we'll make up for it with three pre-Crisis reviews this month, including new contributions from regular writers Joe Crowe and Bill Morse, as well as the first part of a special look at Alan Moore's "Whatever Happened to the Man of Tomorrow," by Jenny Stosser. Also note that we've changed the name of the pre-Crisis section to THE PHANTOM ZONE, hopefully to serve as a fond link to the great stories of the past! ______________________________________________________________ THE PHANTOM ZONE: Reviews of the pre-Crisis Man of Steel -------------------------------------------------------- "WHATEVER HAPPENED TO THE MAN OF TOMORROW" ---------------------------------------- Written by Alan Moore Review and Comments by Jenny Stosser Being the last Superman story, it was inevitable and necessary that this work wrap up a lot of loose ends in the Superman saga. Given that Alan Moore writes as cleverly as he does, it was also inevitable that there be some unexpected plot twists. We all thought we knew Superman and his "family" of characters, but this story really surprised many of us. Alan Moore has a way of taking the known and making it unfamiliar and unexpected. Part One: SUPERMAN #423, September 1986 The story begins with a reminder of the old silver age stories, saying that it is an "imaginary story, which may never happen, but then again may" (the Silver Age Imaginary Stories always began that way). The twist is that the intro finishes with the words: "This is an imaginary story... Aren't they all?" Lois Elliot (nee Lois Lane) is to be interviewed for an article in the Daily Planet's Superman Memorial Edition, the article entitled, "The Last Days of Superman". It appears that Lois is happily married and their baby is asleep, so the timing for the interview is fine. The journalist is a bit nervous about interviewing someone like Lois, but she guides him with a deft hand. (It is apparent that she is no longer a working journalist.) We are quickly drawn into the story, and we learn that two of Superman's more humorous enemies, The Parasite and Terra-Man are no longer a threat, while Lex Luthor is nowhere to be found, and Brainiac's body is no longer viable, taking care of two of his more serious enemies. At the time Lois speaks of, Superman apparently now spends his time doing research for the government. Quite suddenly, things start to go wrong. Bizarro appears and wrecks Metropolis, having destroyed the Bizarro home-world, Htrae, and eventually committing suicide, because according to his warped (er, Bizarre?) logic, if Superman is alive, Bizarro must be dead to be a perfectly imperfect duplicate. A short while later, at WGBS (where Clark Kent and Lana Lang are on-air anchors for the nightly news), a box of altered Superman dolls are delivered for Clark. The alteration has them shooting lasers at Clark, and destroying his suit, revealing him to be Superman to the world. Superman wastes no time trying to deny the truth or even to deal with his friends' reactions, but moves immediately into his Superman persona. It turns out that the toys were sent by two more of the humorous villains, The Toyman and The Prankster. Another one of the toys has a radio transmitter through which the villains speak to Superman, and they reveal that in another package they have sent to Clark is the dead body of Pete Ross, who was brainwashed (tortured?) into telling them The Secret Identity. (If you recall, Pete was one of the few who knew Superman's identity in the pre-Byrne continuity, although he doesn't in the current version.) Superman traces the radio waves back to the villains, and they give in immediately. Suddenly they become once again the simple people they used to be; it would appear they had been mentally coerced into becoming murderers. At Pete's funeral, Superman worries: "If the nuisances from my past are coming back as "killers"... what happens when the "killers"come back?" Cut to Luthor trekking through the arctic wastes, and finding the head of the robot Brainiac in the snow. Apparently the consciousness of the robot villain has been in hibernation in the head, and much to Luthor's surprise, it manages to take him over and take control of his body. They vanish over the horizon. Meanwhile in Metropolis... an army of Metallos attacks the Daily Planet, intending to kill all of Clark Kent's friends ("the way Kent killed my brother"). Jimmy calls Superman on his signal watch, and Superman arrives just in time to save Lois from falling from the building. Superman manages to stop the Metallos and have them imprisoned, then arranges for all of his friends (Lana, Jimmy, Lois, Perry and his wife Alice) to stay at his Fortress of Solitude at the North Pole for safety. Krypto, Superman's pet dog arrives shortly after that, although it isn't explained how he knew to turn up. They got out of Metropolis just in time, as The Kryptonite Man arrives in town on a rampage. He is taken on board by the new Luthor-Brainiac "team" as an assassination weapon against Superman. In the Fortress, Alice & Perry go to separate beds (apparently they had been going through a rough patch in their marriage), but Lois & Lana, though having been "rivals, uneasy friends and finally strangers," comfort each other, talking about their fears for Superman, and eventually fall asleep. Superman, who doesn't need sleep, wanders the fortress with Krypto, and as he passes a portrait of the late Supergirl (Kara Zor-El, who was killed recently in the Crisis on Infinite Earths), he is visited by a young version of The Legion of Super-Heroes from the 30th Century, including the young Supergirl. (I'm fairly certain the costume she is shown wearing is the first one she had - straight blue skirt with a ruffle at the hem?) Brainiac 5 begins to explain to Superman that they are there to present him with a statuette of himself holding a Phantom Zone projector. Superman takes Brainiac 5 to task for allowing Kara to join them on this trip (and the suggestion is there that Supergirl hears this conversation, though she doesn't say anything about it), as she is dead in this era. The other side of the coin is that Invisible Kid is also in the LSH contingent, and he dies later in the 30th Century, though Superman can't tell them that. Superman becomes convinced that he is going to die, and that is the reason for all the loose ends tying up and the Legion's visit. The Legion returns to their time in their time bubble, and although Lois was never told the whole story of what happened that night, it appeared to her that Superman also cried the rest of the night out. This "imaginary story" concluded in Action Comics #583, and my review of that conclusion will be in next month's Kryptonian Cybernet. A few words about the execution of this wonderful story before I finish for this month: The artists were well chosen for such an important story in the Superman saga. Curt Swan is one of the artists whose work will always be associated with Superman. I don't know how long he worked on the Superman books, but whenever I think of old Superman stories, images of his artwork and Kurt Schaffenberger's stick in my mind. George Perez had worked on Superman prior to this story, and at the time that this appeared, he was definitely a fan-favorite (in part due to his work on Crisis). (And mine, too!) The overall effect of the art is one of clarity. It should also be remembered that Alan Moore is known for describing in great detail how he wants his stories to look, so images such as the beads of sweat on Luthor's face when he/Brainiac abduct The Kryptonite Man or those during the Legion's visit, where Supergirl's presence is not revealed until the second panel of their arrival (p21) and the impression that she has heard Superman and Brainiac 5 discussing her demise are certainly intended to be there by the writer. It is not through images alone that this story is told - Alan Moore uses words beautifully to describe images: When Superman catches Lois falling from the Planet building she reminds us that "the reds and blues ran together... so that's how he looked when he flew... a violet comet." (p23); And the shiver still goes down my spine every time I re-read Superman's explanation to the young Supergirl as to why she is not immaterial here and now even though (to her knowledge) she still lives in this era: "Right now, Supergirl... Supergirl is in the "past"." (p23) Finally, I wanted to mention the Metropolis Mailbag, which in this issue is not a letters page, but rather a history of Superman in his own title, written by the late, great (Answer Man) E. Nelson Bridwell. All in all, this first part of the last Superman story is a great one for remembering all the great stories and characters of the past. Jenny Stosser jennys@melbpc.org.au ______________________________________________________________ THE SILVER AGE SUPERMAN ----------------------- by Bill Morse (billmorse@aol.com) Superman-Red and Superman-Blue Another of the most satisfying Silver Age Superman stories is, not surprisingly, an Imaginary Three-Part Novel. Unlike my last review, the Silver Age Death of Superman, this story is a real UP. It's a fantasy about what would happen if Superman could finally solve all of his problems, and live happily ever after. "The Amazing Story of Superman-Red and Superman-Blue" first appeared in Superman #162, in 1963. It was most recently reprinted in "The Greatest Superman Stories Ever Told". Just in case you haven't read any of my other reviews, this book is truly the best Superman stories. No need to hype it - it's great. I believe the hardcover version is out of print, but the trade paperback is still available. If you don't have it, GET IT!!! The story was by Leo Dorfman, and the art was by Curt Swan, inked by that Silver Age staple, George Klein, except for cameo inking of Lois' and Lana's faces by Kurt Schaffenberger. We begin on a day in which Superman is confronted with his failures. Clark's co-workers all get raises, but not Clark. Then the Kandorians remind him of unfulfilled promises: he has never enlarged their city, he has never found a cure for Kryptonite, he has not eradicated crime on Earth. The Kandorians issue an ultimatum: either live up to his promises within six months, or step aside and allow one of them to take over his role as Superman. Talk about ungrateful! Yeah, sure, you liberated us from Brainiac, and saved the universe a dozen times last year, but what have you done for us lately? With Supergirl's help, Superman takes a desperate gamble: he exposes himself to the rays of all types of Kryptonite combined, in an experimental machine he has been working on, called the Brain-Evolution Machine. Supergirl warns him against the risks, and offers to take his place, but he insists. He orders Supergirl to turn it to maximum power. He feels his mind expanding, and then the booth explodes! When the smoke clears, he has been split into two Supermen. They note that this effect happened once before, cause by red Kryptonite. But then they announce that this time is permanent, and that each of them has increased his brain power by a factor of one hundred. They are identical except for their costumes: one is predominantly red, the other blue. Hence their new names, Superman-Red and Superman-Blue. They don't waste any time before digging into their problems. Within a matter of hours, they transport Kandor to the edge of our solar system, and create a planet core out of an element they developed, Hyper-Magneton. According to their calculations, the core will attract all of the Kryptonite in the universe, and fuse it together, reversing the process which made it deadly. When this has been accomplished, they "terraform" it back to the way it was before Krypton exploded. Next, they enlarge Kandor to its full size. The Kandorians, super-powered under our yellow sun, continue the process of restoring Krypton's natural features, restoring oceans, plant life, even cities, all over the planet. After the restoration is complete, the Kandorians decide to move it to its original position under its red sun, so they can live normal, un-super lives. Next up is a distress call from Lori the mermaid, in Atlantis. Having observed what the Superman have accomplished for the Kandorians, Lori requests a watery world of their own, where mer-people won't be considered freaks. No sooner asked than done. Then they develop an anti-evil hypno-ray, which they mount in satellite projectors, to blanket Earth and surrounding space. The ray even serves to make Communists embrace Capitalism! Proof that it was an evil empire, after all. Alien invaders who come too close to Earth reform their ways. Luthor reforms, and invents a super-serum that cures all known diseases. (Although I would bet his own formidable intellect was surely outclassed by the Supermen's enhanced Kryptonian brains.) Suddenly, the blind, lame, even the bald, are in perfect health. Supergirl releases the Phantom Zone criminals, who of course, are no longer evil. They decide to journey to New Krypton, and Supergirl reveals that she wants to join them there. Luthor alerts the Supermen to a sighting of Mr. Mxyzptlk. But the imp, too, is permanently reformed. Their problems solved, the Supermen turn to their own lives. They want to marry. Blue reveals that he loves Lana, and fortunately, Red loves Lois. They reveal their identities, and have a double wedding. Since there are so many good vibes in the air, Jimmy Olsen and Lucy Lane make it a triple wedding. Then it turns out that Red longs to go live on New Krypton. Lois is only too happy to oblige. Blue prefers to stay on Earth, and that pleases Lana. He announces his retirement, and programs his robots to handle natural disasters. Both Supermen start families, and both have twins. For once, everyone is happy, and the universe is a utopia. But in the last panel, as Jimmy and Lucy look at a scrapbook of the two super-families, Jimmy muses that they have all gotten what they wanted. Lucy has the last word, though, as she says, "Hm! I wonder!" This story doesn't have the undercurrents of tragedy that the best of the Imaginary Stories share, but it is a refreshing change to see how everything could have turned out for Superman and his friends. ______________________________________________________________ BRAVE AND THE BOLD #150: Batman & ? "Today Gotham...Tomorrow, the World!" May 1979 Writer: Bob Haney Artist: Jim Aparo Cover Price: .40 Rating: 2.9 shields Batman shadows a businessman whom a murderous terrorist gang called the Battalion of Doom has targeted for kidnapping. In broad daylight, the gang nabs the businessman. Batman leaps after them, but they make their escape. The Battalion leaves a message: their next victim will be Bruce Wayne. A museum curator friend of Wayne calls him to inform him that a print from his father's art collection has been stolen. Wayne hangs up the phone -- and it's been booby-trapped. Wayne is knocked out by an electric shock, and wakes up in a cell. His kidnappers inform him that all the other hostages are being held separately, and they will be executed if Gotham doesn't surrender all power to them. Wayne will be guarded by Keeper Karns, a giant goon. Wayne tries to escape, but Karns clobbers him. Wayne thinks that he could've gone full blast, but Karns would get suspicious. After Karns leaves, Wayne makes a rope from the bed and exits through the roof. As Batman, he finds that Alfred has also been snatched. Batman disregards as meaningless information about the stolen print of his father's: it was a drawing of an old mining company's location in Gotham. As Wayne, Batman heads back to his prison and gets reeled in by his rope. It's Karns, and he clobbers Wayne again. Then the Battalion comes in with the businessman they captured earlier. They execute him in front of Wayne, then tell Keeper to take him out and dump him. Later, Bruce yanks off a bedpost and challenges Karns. The goon *phases* through the wall. Bruce whacks him anyway with the post, and Karns goes down? Not bothering to wonder why, Bruce escapes again and becomes Batman. He meets Commissioner Gordon at the morgue, where they find the body of the businessman. The guy then sits up on the gurney. His wounds have been tended to "as if by a master surgeon!" Batman exits, and runs into Keeper on the street. Keeper calls him "Wayne" and at superhuman speed, Karns books back to the Battalion's nest with Batman. Batman wonders what super-villain has all the powers that Keeper has displayed. The Battalion says that Wayne AND Keeper are in trouble, and that they will detonate an atomic device in Gotham if their demands aren't met. They bring in Alfred, and line him up to be shot. Karns steps in front of the shots, and Bruce and Alfred cut out. Karns follows them. The terrorists fire at them -- and Karns zaps the bullets out of the sky with heat vision. Keeper Karns is really (surprise!) Superman. The Big S reveals that he had to go undercover because Jimmy Olsen was also kidnapped by the Battalion, and that they said they would cack Jimmy if Superman came to Gotham. Superman wasn't sure if the silo was bugged, so he couldn't reveal his secret to Wayne. He had no idea that Bruce would be kidnapped as well -- so he let Bruce escape, hoping that as Batman he could solve the crime while he was free, and get him back to his cell on time so the Battalion wouldn't suspect. He also did super-surgery on the businessman to save his life. A clue found by Alfred helps the World's Finest boys find the hostages, and Commissioner Gordon orders a raid. The police free all the hostages, but nobody finds Jimmy Olsen. He's apparently with the atomic device, to keep Superman from interfering. Finally Batman figures out the deal with the stolen art print. It was the only clue to the location of their headquarters. It's in a mine, and the lead walls kept Superman from finding it. Disguised as a sewer inspector, Superman busts in there, rescues Jimmy, and throws the bomb into orbit, where it explodes harmlessly. This was a pretty neat little story. Batman and Superman teamed up every single month in WORLD'S FINEST, but this was better than most of those. The WF formula consisted of one of the two big guys having a problem, calling up their best buddy, the taking care of business together. And that was it. Here, Superman and Batman were on different ends of the problem, and meeting each other was really just a happy accident. There was even a threat worthy of a team-up. There aren't many super-hero team-ups where one of the stars is a mystery. Probably because the main purpose of a team-up is to pump sales up by plastering the guest star all over the cover. However, the B&B people didn't worry about that. They let the story sell the book. Those were the days. There also weren't any real clues to Karns' identity -- we never saw his thought balloons. Batman's the greatest detective in the world and Superman's concerned about keeping his ID secret too -- he really thumped on Bruce pretty good. Maybe Superman was so worried about Jimmy, and Batman was so stymied by the situation, that neither of them were at full throttle. But there you go -- weaknesses of two franchise characters coming to play in a single story. In 1979, that was a freaky occurrence. Super-freaky. :) Joe Crowe (j.crowe4@genie.geis.com) ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 6 ________________________________________________________________ LOIS AND CLARK: THE NEW ADVENTURES OF SUPERMAN ---------------------------------------------- (Boy could we use a real title for this section! :) Before we get to Zoomway's article and the review of the season premiere, I wanted to briefly introduce the forces behind the third season. While the cast remains the same (excepting Teri Hatcher's wonderful new hairdo), the executive staff has undergone some changes and shuffling: Co-Producers: Chris Long Grant Rosenberg Jim Michaels Producers: Philip J. Sgriccia Jimmy Simons Supervising Producers: Chris Ruppenthal John McNamara Co-Executive Producers: Eugenie Ross-Lemming Brad Buckner Executive Producer: Robert Singer Let's hope these guys can make it through an entire season (Hey! It's yet to happen!) In addition, here are the writing and directing credits for the four episodes which have already aired: 1. "We Have A Lot To Talk About" (9/17) Writer: John McNamara Director: Philip J. Sgriccia 2. "Ordinary People" (9/24) Writers: Eugenie Ross-Lemming & Brad Buckner Director: Michael Watkins 3. "Contact" (10/1) Writer: Chris Ruppenthal Director: Daniel Attias 4. "When Irish Eyes Are Killing" (10/15) Writer: Grant Rosenberg Director: Winriche Kolbe And one final programming note. Sunday night's episode (10/22) will *not* be pre-empted by the World Series. NBC will be covering that game. However, if the series goes a full seven games, the final game will be Sunday night, 10/29, on ABC. This will cause L&C to be pre- empted that night. However, as far as I know, if the Series is over by then, the show will air as expected. Jeff Sykes ______________________________________________________________ SIGH-FI ------- by Zoomway (Zoomway@aol.com) Way back, maybe my first article for this august publication, I stated that I did not consider "Lois and Clark: The New Adventures of Superman" to be science fiction, and felt it more deserving of the title fantasy. Fortunately, there is a new term, 'sigh'-fi. It refers to a brand of soft SF with an emphasis on characterization, and a generous nod to romance. There was no doubt, as season three premiered with WE HAVE A LOT TO TALK ABOUT, that Lois and Clark is 'definitely' sigh-fi. In WE HAVE A LOT TO TALK ABOUT, Lois removes Clark Kent's glasses and lets Clark, and the television audience, know that she has figured out his secret. This was so startling to some viewers that they thought it had to be a dream sequence. It was so powerful a shock that in CONTACT, the third episode aired this season, many felt that after Lois was knocked unconscious, she would wake up and forget the secret, but she still knows. Lois knowing Clark's secret has added depth to the characters, the humor, and opened avenues to storylines that would never have been possible with Lois left in the dark. By letting the characters evolve, as all 'real' people must, the writers/producers have set up a kind of empathy with Lois and Clark that most viewers are completely unfamiliar with. Viewers, especially American viewers, are jaded, and that's why they expected the revelation to be a dream, and that Lois would forget the secret. They simply are not prepared for a show to move forward and make it 'real'. They are so used to being yanked around, frustrated, and set back, that having a show move counter to those deeply ingrained truisms of TV is causing an ever widening audience to tune in, some just to see what rule they will break next. The majority of new viewers, however, have found a show they never knew existed, and they are having fun with the discovery. "Lois and Clark", in part, can thank the competition for many of these new viewers. NBC, conceding defeat in the head-to-head competition between "seaQuest" and "Lois and Clark", moved out "seaQuest" and moved in one of its few power hitters, "Mad About You", and its follow up show from Thursday nights, "Hope & Gloria". CBS, wanting to win over a piece of the youth market on Sunday night, where higher advertising dollars are spent, moved its ratings champ, "Murder She Wrote", and replaced it with "Cybill" and a lesser known sitcom, "Almost Perfect". This left "Lois and Clark" all alone as the only one hour program in the 8-9 time slot, and the only non-sitcom as well. This shortsightedness on the part of the competition has given "Lois and Clark" the best ratings for a fledgling season to date. Audiences seem to be responding to the sigh-fi approach, and the unique signature it gives an already unique television program. I mean, how many other shows would have a woman shouting to her boyfriend, "That is so unfair! You know I can't fly!" as he ascends into the night sky? What other show could have a couple engaged in a lover's quarrel that would include this exchange: "What took you an hour?" "A nuclear reactor meltdown in Philadelphia. What's your point?" And yet, the show can turn right around and have Clark telling Lois how he feels about her, in a very real, and touching way, and not even miss a beat. No other show can do this, and no other show has ever tried. Why do the surreal elements of Superman and his universe of unconventional villains blend so well with an honest approach to a romance? Well, let's just say it's magic, because even analyzing the show's appeal in the more conventional sense, still seems to add up to magic, or, considering how many rules this show has broken, maybe 'miracle' would say it better. Now the show is in motion for the new season; Lois knows that Clark is Superman, she is contemplating his proposal of marriage, they are learning how to be a team on new levels, and as with any relationship, they have problems to overcome, except with Lois and Clark, the problems are a bit more irregular than most. Lois now knows that when Clark gets that 'look', the one that used to precede lame excuses like checking out his cheese of the month shipment, it actually means Clark is hearing someone who needs Superman, and Lois has to be prepared for damage control when he leaves. Knowing the answer to why Clark had always dashed off mysteriously finally sets Lois' mind at ease about Clark having a fear of commitment to their relationship, but it also leaves her with the question of where she fits in to his commitment to Metropolis. The first three episodes have just barely scratched the surface on the possibilities facing Lois and Clark in the season(s) ahead. The future actually does look like the Lois and Clark Expedition. ======================================================== EPISODE REVIEW: --------------- Episode #3-01: "We Have A Lot To Talk About" -------------------------------------------- by Marta Olson US Airdate: September 17, 1995 Special Guest Stars: Bruce Campbell, and Peter Boyle as "Bill Church" Guest Starring: Jessica Collins and Sal Viscuso Written by: John McNamara Directed by: Philip J. Sgriccia Clark, on bended knee, opened the ring box and asked THE question "Will you marry me?" Rain coming down all around them, Lois paused. I paused too. Even though I had heard what her answer would be I held my breath. Would they really do it? Or would everything from the last episode of season two ("And The Answer Is...") be forgotten. I watched as Lois leaned forward, took Clark's glasses off and said "Who's asking, you or Superman?" THEY ACTUALLY DID IT! I felt like sitting and chanting, "Lois knows, Lois knows," but then the show was back. So was the emotional roller coaster we left several months ago. Lois now knows Clark's deepest secret. She has conflicting emotions and could not say yes - yet. Unfortunately Clark heard only the no. Of course, it would not be this show if their conversation were not interrupted with a cry for help. Only this time, Clark hesitates and Lois urges him to go on. We, the fans, had been asking for four things from the show. In this episode we were given three of them - the revelation was the first. The second was later when Martha and Jonathan come to Metropolis. Martha has a talk with Lois and we find out more about Clark's background and the loneliness he has always felt. At the age of 13 he made the decision to hide who he really was, and as a consequence never felt like he fit in. This scene also has one of the more memorable lines from this episode - "almost thirty years and you're the first woman I can talk to about my boy." This episode has many lines that are great, mostly from Lois. "That is so unfair! You know I can't fly." as Superman leaves when Lois turns down his proposal. "I'm the one who was lied to, don't you be petulant!" during an argument. After Lois says, "You're Superman," Clark replies "A little louder, I don't think they heard you in Gotham". My favorite, though, is when Lois says "When were you going to tell me, our first anniversary? When the kids started flying around the house?" There is one scene that, to me, was really symbolic of how Clark is feeling. As Clark, he takes the ring he offered to Lois with his heart and throws it into space after an argument. As it floats through space, Superman appears and reaches out to grab it. Then almost as if he changes his mind, he opens his hand and lets the ring float away again, only to firmly regrasp it -- as if his decision is made and he will not let her go away from him. The third thing we had been asking for was a "flying makeout scene." We were given that at the end. I won't say too much about it other than to say how wonderful it was, and that it did remind me of E.T. I haven't mentioned the villains yet or their deeds. We are reintroduced to Bill Church, who has had a change of heart and has pledged to use the Church fortune to make the world a better place. He starts out with creating an organization called "The Church Group" which virtually renders Superman unneeded. Bill Church has remarried a woman named Mindi who turns out to be something different than she appears. Bill Church Jr. comes back to town after being in the Orient and settling a territorial spat with the Yakuza. The result? CostMarts going up all over the Orient. There is so much more in this episode - Lois finds out that a bomb specialist is in town and has his sights set on the museum. They decide to kill her but need to get rid of Superman first. Superman is out of town fixing a reactor leak while Lois is jumping for her life. At the end, Lois and Clark have to work together to disarm the bomb at the museum. I don't want to say too much more about this episode. If you haven't seen it yet, please do. It is well worth the time. ______________________________________________________________ THE MAILBAG ----------- Rich Morrissey has provided us some additional information about "Superman From the 30's to the 70's," which was reviewed last month by J.D. Rummel in his AND WHO DISGUISED AS... column: Dear Jeffery, Just got KC #17 online: it came through very nicely! I enjoyed it all, but my favorite sections were "Just the FAQs" by David Chappell and the review of "Superman From the 30's to the 70's" by J.D. Rummel. Since he expressed his disappointment at the lack of credits in the book, I'm sending both you and him a copy of a list I worked out with my friend Martin O'Hearn, an expert on both writing and art styles at Golden and Silver Age DC. Most of these credits, especially those to Jerry Siegel, Otto Binder, and Alvin Schwartz, have been confirmed by the writers. This list includes both the aforementioned book and its later reissue, "Superman From the 30s to the 80s," whose missing apostrophes reflect a change in preferred style. I've made notations made as to which stories appeared in only one or the other of the books. Titles in parentheses are descriptive ones for originally-untitled stories. 1. ("Revolution in San Monte, Part I") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Joe Shuster Superman #1, Summer 1939, expanded from Action Comics #1, June 1938. (First 9 pages in color in "Superman From the 30's to the 70's," first two pages in color in "Superman From the 30s to the 80s") 2. ("Revolution in San Monte, Part II") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Joe Shuster Action Comics #2, July 1938 3. ("Luthor and the Earthquake Machine") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Joe Shuster Superman #4, Spring 1940 4. ("The Sky-Sub Intrigue") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Joe Shuster shop Superman #10, May-June 1941 5. ("The Light") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Leo Novak Superman #13, November-December 1941 6. ("The Archer") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Leo Novak Superman #13, November-December 1941 7. ("The Napkan Saboteurs") (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Leo Novak Superman #15, March-April 1942 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 8. "How Clark Kent Met Lois Lane" (w)Bill Finger (p)Al Wenzel? (i)John Sikela? Adventure Comics #128, May 1948 (out of sequence!) 9. "Man or Superman?" (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Joe Shuster shop Superman #17, July-August 1942 (In color in "Superman From the 30's to the 70's," page 7 missing in both versions) 10. "Case of the Funny Paper Crimes" (w)Jerry Siegel (p)Ed Dobrotka? (i)John Sikela Superman #19, November-December 1942 11. "Superman, Matinee Idol" (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Joe Shuster Superman #19, November-December 1942 (minus one page and with some dialogue concerning Siegel and Shuster changed) 12. "America's Secret Weapon" (w)Don Cameron (p)Sam Citron (i)John Sikela Superman #23, July-August 1943 13. "The Mysterious Mr. Mxyztplk" (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Ira Yarbrough Superman #30, September-October 1944 14. "Lois Lane, Superwoman" (w)Alvin Schwartz (a)John Sikela Superman #43, March-April 1947 (Taken from a British reprint that made some unusual changes, most notably the change of dollars to "guineas") 15. "The Battle of the Atoms" (w)Don Cameron (a)Sam Citron Superman #38, January-February 1946 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only, in which it is slightly out of sequence) 16. "The Origin of Superman" (w)Bill Finger (p)Wayne Boring (i)Stan Kaye Superman #53, July-August 1948 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 17. "Black Magic on Mars" (a)Wayne Boring Superman #62, January-February 1950 18. "The Mightiest Team in the World" (w)Edmond Hamilton (p)Curt Swan (i)John Fischetti? Superman #76, May-June 1952 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 19. "The Girls in Superman's Life" (w)Edmond Hamilton (a)Al Plastino Superman #78, September-October 1952 20. "The Terrible Trio" (w)William Woolfolk (p)Wayne Boring (i)Stan Kaye Superman #88, March 1954 21. "The Girl in Superman's Past" (w)Bill Finger (a)Wayne Boring Superman #129, May 1959 22. "The Supergirl from Krypton" (w)Otto Binder (a)Al Plastino Action Comics #252, May 1959 (Superman From the 30s to the 80s only) 23. "The Super-Duel in Space" (w)Otto Binder (a)Al Plastino Action Comics #242, July 1958 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only -- out of sequence) 24. "How Luthor Met Superboy" (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Al Plastino Adventure Comics #271, April 1960 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only) 25. "The Untold Story of Red Kryptonite" (w)Otto Binder (p)Curt Swan (i)John Forte Superman #139, August 1960 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 26. "The Son of Bizarro" (w)Otto Binder (a)Wayne Boring Superman #140, October 1960 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 27. "Superman Meets Al Capone" (w)Otto Binder (a)Wayne Boring Superman #142, January 1961 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 28. "Bizarro Meets Frankenstein" (w)Otto Binder (p)Wayne Boring (i)George Klein Superman #143, February 1961 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 29. "Superboy's First Public Appearance" (w)Jerry Siegel (a)Al Plastino Superman #144, April 1961 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 30. "The Showdown Between Luthor and Superman" (w)Edmond Hamilton (p)Curt Swan (i)George Klein Superman #164, October 1963 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only) 31. "The Origin of Superman" (plot and layouts)Carmine Infantino (script)E. Nelson Bridwell (p) Curt Swan (i) Murphy Anderson The Amazing World of Superman, Metropolis Edition, 1973 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only -- published in color) 32. "The Pied Piper of Steel" (w)Leo Dorfman (p)Curt Swan (i)Murphy Anderson Action Comics #398, March 1971 (First nine pages in color in "Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only) 33. "Superman Breaks Loose" (w)Denny O'Neil (p)Curt Swan (i)Murphy Anderson Superman #233, January 1971 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only -- out of sequence) 34. "Superman, You're Dead-Dead-Dead" (w)Leo Dorfman (p)Curt Swan (i)Murphy Anderson Action Comics #399, February 1971 35. "Duel of Doom" (w)Leo Dorfman (p)Curt Swan (i)Murphy Anderson Action Comics #400, March 1971 ("Superman From the 30's to the 70's" only -- "Geoff Browne" was an acknowledged pseudonym of Dorfman) 36. "The Miraculous Return of Jonathan Kent" (w)Cary Bates (p)Curt Swan (i)Frank Chiarmonte Action Comics #507, May 1980 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only) 37. "The Secret World of Jonathan Kent" (w)Cary Bates (p)Curt Swan (i)Frank Chiarmonte Action Comics #508, June 1980 ("Superman From the 30s to the 80s" only) A good article on kryptonite, though I'll acknowledge that I don't find Byrne's version any more logical than the one Bill Finger first developed in SUPERMAN #61. Kryptonians are clearly different enough from Earth people to have all those powers, why is it impossible that they might also be susceptible to certain types of radiation with little or no effect on human beings. And does Luthor's being affected by kryptonite radiation indicate some distant Kryptonian ancestry on his own part? (Come to think of it, why can't the people who gave Luthor a working artificial hand do the same for Aquaman? I wish they'd at least TRY to keep technology consistent in the DC Universe.) Byrne's contention that kryptonite had different powers in different universes also flies in the face of established DC lore, in which kryptonite was the same no matter what universe it was in (as when Superman went to Earth-2 or some other parallel Earth). Ah, well... Rich Morrissey RMorris306@aol.com ======================================================== I enjoyed David T. Chappell's Kryptonite FAQ in the last KC: "A Rainbow of Rocks" indeed! Very informative and covers more varieties I think than Michael Fleisher did in his now-outdated Encyclopedia. I only wish Mr. Chappell had included some issue numbers, or at least some dates or creative teams, in his history lesson. All in all, I usually enjoy the Silver Age articles the most and wish that someday we could see a feature on some of the comic book artists from that period like Swan/Anderson and Wayne Boring. If anyone has had a chance to flip through the recently published "Good Taste Gone Bad," it becomes apparent just what an affect these artists have had on the popular imagination. Bryan Munn bmunn@uoguelph.ca ______________________________________________________________ **************************************************************** End of Section 7/Issue #18